Loren Maxwell's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 160734534 | Mild vandalism was from v5, not v7 |
|
| 93471582 | This changeset appears to be vandalism. |
|
| 160575117 | One of the threads of this broad discussion here: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/proposed-double-entry-of-consolidated-city-counties/122459/ Basically, `place` tags can be removed on a relation with `boundary=administrative` if the label node has a `place` tag |
|
| 160518131 | Well, it's true I made *a* change to that wiki page, but I did not make *that* change. border_type=state has been there since the 2009 version by Skippern:
In 2017 it was cleaned up to the current format by stevea:
You might be able to contact either of them to find out why they did that -- I know stevea is still very active on OSM US and he's pretty approachable. I tagged them border_type=state for 1) consistency since 14 of the states had it, 36 did not, 2) I use it in the way I described in my other response, 3) and in this post we discussed adding border_type=* to boundaries in the US: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/proposed-double-entry-of-consolidated-city-counties/122459 Perhaps this upset your use of the data in some way? What was your work around for the 14 states that had border_type=state? |
|
| 160518131 | On that page, under Country specific / United States, border_type=state corresponds to admin_level-4. 14 of the states had border_type tags, 36 did not. Every county, parish, and borough in the US have a border_type tag, and in the forum we've discussed that every boundary=administrative should have a border_type tag. This also allows easy filtering in Overpass. For example, this query returns over 70 results: ```
Included are the US territories, the District of Columbia, three Canadian provinces where the US and Canada have a border dispute, several farm management areas, etc. This query slightly improves the situation: ```
But it still returns 59 results, including the US territories, the three Canadian provinces, and DC. However this query:
Returns the 50 states. All border_type=state are admin_level=4, but not all admin_level=4 are border_type=state. |