OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
181942535

I did think about `ref:*-HK:KMB` vs `ref:*:HK:KMB=` , decided to fold into the former to match localization, and avoid over-namespacing (although hyphen for the locale string is borderline)

181942535

HI, sorry for the `ref-HK` typo. But the problem is they have a Chinese code which would be eg `ref:zh-HK:KMB`

178578447

Forgot about here: Yes there is, there are 2 lanes to Chui Yu Rd on this side, and it's signposted https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=813714736238904&focus=photo

181767161

Why?

181750843

1. `name=` duplicates `distance=`
3. Wrong `description ` as explained (NTCR measures via Nathan Rd from TST)

181699735

The `landuse=construction` is for `landuse=highway`

181700817

I suggest no need to be bilingual in `description=` to avoid any problem with 255char length limit (and reduce user effort)

179066259

One might experiment with "eyeballing". But it should be validated with known correct cases.

179066259

I will add that it seems contradictory to align through 2 buildings of Upper Wong Tai Sin Estate. Not aligning through Fung Tak EAP directly is suspicious. In historical imagery (Esri Clarity, Wayback), it can be further seen Fung Tak EAP is the works shaft.
Tunneling under podium is possible, and towers especially hillside. Underpinning is not uncommon either. Disruption or risk to Lung Cheung Rd is a bigger concern. Wong Tai Sin Telephone Exchange would be almost impossible to divert.

181634655

`access=no` is unneeded on `=construction` , as it may be forgotten to be removed, or suggest it will be constructed to become `access=no`

181612941

They may want to go to the basement. This is a possible option. It's sheltered, air-conditioned, and has escalators. In the future, it should be connecting entire WKCD.

181505097

Ok, you want "non-localized"?

181612941

Please don't delete the parts tunneled/indoors. This breaks routing.

181613710

Please don't draw a `highway=` + `area=yes` /`area:highway=` slightly away when it's bounded from a `=kerb`

181505097

What's the logic here? It's a localized identifier being replaced by a national identifier. Why should they use the same attribute?

181505097

1. This only explained the 3-char code, not the 5-char code
2. The question is exactly about the 5-char being different from the 3-char, thus not being `local_ref=`

181562515

In other countries, it might not be the same as `=kerb` when there's `crossing:kerb_extension=` (avoid using this, many problems)

181560418

It's commonly said as in Chi Ma Wan, and is inside the Bay. Is it as significant and top level as others?

181589191

Why is this correct? There's a car parked on it from Bing, and Esri Clarity.

181562515

Technically `highway=traffic_signal` on `=footway` may be allowed, as it is done on `=cycleway`