OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
183673105

Thank you for catching! Fixed in changeset/183878212

172032966

My fix is still in review and hasn't made it into upstream Valhalla yet, so the upstream maintainers of Valhalla are asking to revert this change for now. I'm a bit concerned this will hide the underlying bug in Valhalla but I was able to extract a pretty small extract of the OSM data to reproduce the bug which should allow us to test the fix independently of this change being rolled back.

172032966

I'm not sure there's a minimum per se, but I think it's somewhat unusual to have so many points around a corner like this. Might be best to ask in the OSM discord! https://discord.gg/openstreetmap

For what it's worth, this change revealed a very subtle bug in Valhalla and I was able to submit a patch to fix it :): https://github.com/valhalla/valhalla/pull/5529

172032966

https://github.com/valhalla/valhalla/issues/5521 for further discussion on the downstream breakage.

172032966

This change seems to have broken Valhalla, and has added a significant number of nodes, in some cases hundreds of nodes within meters of each other along ways. E.g. node/13148097576#map=19/45.646311/-74.360544