OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
115349210 about 4 years ago

I added the `motor_vehicle=private` tag because it is connected to a gate and service highway with the same tag. Without any additional restrictions, the `oneway=yes` tag forces any vehicle into this private area. The image you linked shows a vehicle facing west. Do you think it would be most appropriate to remove the `oneway=yes` tag?

115308998 about 4 years ago

Thanks for the comments literan, we understand your points and will make sure to do that going forward. We are currently pausing this project in Moscow to go over your suggestions with the team. We will also go back and fix the issues.

115306773 about 4 years ago

I see the issue here. It looks like `motor_vehicle=private` is the more logical tag for the service roads in this area.

115269835 about 4 years ago

I had added the `access=private` tag because it is connected to a gate and service highway with the same tag. Because the `highway=pedestrian` way it connects to [way/29854275] is tagged with `motor_vehicle=no,` do you think that would be a more appropriate tag? Otherwise, I see similar situations in this area where `motor_vehicle=private` tags exist.

115220301 about 4 years ago

My bad! I was drafting up a response and accidentally sent that instead. I had been thinking there might have been a data issue here because of the switch from service to track (that's what I meant by classification gap), but after looking at it again I agree with you that the road should be a track like you initially modeled it. Thank you for your close attention to detail in Moscow, and happy mapping!

115220301 about 4 years ago

way/415477390] crates classification gap between service roads [way/542911419 and way/413449586] that resulted sink islands. [way/415477390] access some service facilities in the area, per service road definition in Russia wiki “A minor road providing primary access to a commercial or industrial facility. See highway=service.”

114194996 about 4 years ago

Yandex Panorama

112474982 about 4 years ago

OSM

112474982 about 4 years ago

Source = OSM Data

112140707 over 4 years ago

Maxar Premium Imagery (5.97; -3.58); Strava

111776345 over 4 years ago

Bing Aerial Imagery

110985430 over 4 years ago

Maxar SecureWatch 2021-09-07

110998009 over 4 years ago

Maxar SecureWatch Imagery 2021-06-16

110940542 over 4 years ago

Maxar SecureWatch Imagery 2021-06-16

110988520 over 4 years ago

Maxar SecureWatch 2021-06-16

110988520 over 4 years ago

SecureWatch 2021-06-16

110980974 over 4 years ago

Maxar SecureWatch Imagery 2021-06-16

108911115 over 4 years ago

The alignment was made with Maxar Premium Imagery.

107172163 over 4 years ago

Unclassified road alignment East of Πελεή hamlet #adt
Source Maxar Premium Imagery

107112592 over 4 years ago

Maxar Premium Imagery (Beta)