GOwin's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 190999302 | This looks great! 🫡 I noticed (on Bing and Maxar imagery) that the vegetation and tree shadows follow the inferred watercourse so closely that we might not even need the fixme tags here. What do you think? |
|
| 190951032 | Good job! Thanks for taking the time to review it.👋 |
|
| 190951032 | Hint: when reading a topographic (or contour) map, the elevation labels (the numbers) are almost always oriented to follow the direction of the slope.
|
|
| 190951032 | Hi Angelo. If you look closely at the contour lines in this area, you'll discover that this waterway is impossible, because it's going uphill. In fact, the connecting waterway you found, also suffers from the same issue. I think you'll want to revisit these , and just remove these two elements. And, while you're doing that, I think the waterway to left, is mis-tagged as a "stream" rather than a river. What do you think?
|
|
| 190726465 | Looks good! Thank you for your edits.
|
|
| 190726738 | Thank you for your edits. Next time, don't forget to connect the highway segment to the bride, so that they both share a node. Otherwise, this looks alright.
|
|
| 190208856 | Good job, finding the FairwayMapper editor for OpenStreetMap. Thank you for your edits, and welcome to OpenStreetMap. I hope you're having fun. |
|
| 189192009 | Are you thinking of waterway=stream + intermittent=yes here? It looks like it's something you can trace back to this tributary: 15.212317 121.048114 |
|
| 190233177 | Hi Raf. If you review the entry for waterways in the OSM wiki, don't you think this qualifies as a river rather than a "stream" ?
|
|
| 189459615 | Thank you for your consistent contributions to the project! 🥳
|
|
| 189484671 | Some sections of these mapped waterways are better tagged with waterway=canal + usage=irrigation. Please refer to the wiki for details. A rule of thumb for waterways: if you can jump across it, it's a stream. Please go over the #ChasingWaterways FAQ for the the documentation and mapping tips: https://hackmd.io/@osmph/H1ZB1J9Tle#Questions
|
|
| 189484783 | Good job. The vegetation is a good indicator that there's very likely a (small) waterway here. You can also use a topo map to confirm this from DEM contours.
|
|
| 188287750 | Do you know that you can add useful photos for these type of POI? Easiest would be via MapComplete, via their memorial theme: https://mapcomplete.org/memorials And then, downstream apps using OpenStreetMap can show them like this to end-users:
|
|
| 188432687 | No biggie, and thank you for the valuable help. We're looking forward to more of your edits. 😉 |
|
| 188432687 | Thank you for helping improve the map! Maybe you overlooked it, but you can also add the extra attributes for the highway. Also, ESRI imagery in this region is usually newer than Bing, so it makes sense to check out the layer, too. Keep up the good work!.
|
|
| 188611489 | Good job! Thanks. The #ChasingWaterways project has an FAQ here: https://hackmd.io/@osmph/H1ZB1J9Tle There's also a casual chat room with fellow waterway chasers: https://i.delta.chat/#BEC7F4ECF589A3B882326E4CD1E9FAAC3F594094&a=7dukx5bbi%40chika.aangat.lahat.computer&g=Chasing%20Waterways&x=_N5JnALdaWAiYVH5eomFTXFO&i=iqjoGqQ5YdthzU2BrXI2wAa9&s=_noE2gfzO70CjYPTU_GNAMQy , where folks can learn from each other.
|
|
| 188050451 | Thank you for your regular contributions to the #ChasingWaterways project! In case you missed it, we have an FAQ, and the pointers for the Hidden Waterways campaign may be specially interesting for you: https://hackmd.io/@osmph/H1ZB1J9Tle#HiddenWaterways-Pointers
|
|
| 187688004 | Hello there! Thank you for contributing to the #ChasingWaterways project. If the waterway is clearly visible from the aerial imagery, do not add the fixme=waterway tag. That tag is only used for the "hidden waterways" that needs a secondary review. You can learn more about the initiative from our FAQ, and specifically, the pointers for the Hidden Waterways campaign here: https://hackmd.io/@osmph/H1ZB1J9Tle#HiddenWaterways-Pointers
|
|
| 188079305 | You're welcome, and I hope you're enjoying editing the map. If you're interested in knowing other contributors, check out the various communication channels ran by local communities: osm.org/wiki/PH |
|
| 188125434 | My bad. You added it yourself, already, and I incorrectly referred to building made five years ago. Thanks! |