Dear Skyper,
thanks for sending these links. About the list of semi-automated imports I am not sure, as they seam to use more automation as we do. We added the process of the permission in the wiki and will add it to the contributors page as soon as we heard back from them. Also, we will double check the sources of the other carsharing operators.

Best,

Dilan

Dear skyper,

Thanks for your reply. We just got in contact with the operators from Grüne Flotte and asked them if they give us the permission to map the locations. I will wait for their answer before adding further locations of this operator.

About the documentation in the wiki page, we have documented our work here: osm.wiki/GOAT_(Geo_Open_Accessibility_Tool). Are you missing any specific information?

Thanks for the hint on the abbreviations. I will make sure to not use them in the future. Also, I removed the address from all my carsharing edits.

Best,

Dilan

Dear Skyper,

Thanks for your comments. For these points, I got the information from the website of Grüne-Flotte. I didn’t find anything on their website that indicates that I am not allowed to use it (https://gruene-flotte.com/impressum/).

I am mapping for an open-source project (https://www.open-accessibility.org/). We are collecting car and bike sharing locations in different regions in Germany to make some statistical analysis. Therefore, we are looking at the official websites of the cities and counties, as well as the car and bike sharing providers. If possible, we do quality checks by looking at aerial and street-view images to verify the position. So theoretically, I am usually having more than one source for the objects I am mapping. So far, we didn’t have any issues with that. But please let me know in case there is something wrong here.

I am only mapping manually, not automated, in order to make sure that there are no duplicates or faults.

Thanks for the hint regarding the addresses! I will not add them in the future.

Best,

Dilan

Hi,
Thanks for feedback. On their own website it says:
Düren-Kreishaus
Düren Zentrum, Düren
Moltkestraße 26
52351 Düren
I did not add the housenumber like you said we do not need since they are stations. I've just added addr:street.
Thanks
Best

I don't remember I put the "bicycle_parking = stands" maybe it was like that before so I didn't want to change it, usually I'm checking if the address tag and station name are correct or not. However, I can add "bicycle_rental = docking_station" instead of "bicycle_parking = stands" if you like.
Thanks
Best

Hi, for the Leonrodplatz Station, I haven't removed any tag on purpose, like I mentioned in the comments, they were no 'brand' tags as MVG Rad so I've added brand tags.
Thanks
Best

Hello, thanks for letting me know. It must be a mistake when copy&paste.
Best.

Hi,
Thanks for your feedback.
I will consider it for my next updates.
Best