Bolt031's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 188654182 | Hello. Thank you for your quick reply. I had modified the map accordingly |
|
| 188654182 | Hi! Could you confirm whether J. Basanavičiaus g. is now open in both directions? way/218900925, way/333506099. I don't have local knowledge, so I'd appreciate a check. Thanks a lot! |
|
| 190916079 | Thanks for the clarification. I understand your reasoning, and I agree that OSM should reflect the situation on the ground. However, I also think consistency in tagging is important. OSM is not a perfect representation of reality, and sometimes there is more than one reasonable way to classify a road. I’m not necessarily arguing for highway=service. highway=living_street could also be considered, especially given the classification of the adjacent segment, while keeping motor_vehicle=destination to preserve the actual access restriction. I agree that we shouldn’t map for a specific router, but I also believe that consistency and usability across different applications matter. After all, the purpose of OSM is not only to represent the real world as accurately as possible, but also to provide data that can be meaningfully used. I appreciate your offer to raise an issue with OSRM. While routing is part of the problem, I’m not sure a change could be easily generalized without affecting other scenarios. That’s why I also think tagging consistency and usability across different applications are important. |
|
| 190916079 | I agree that OSM should reflect the situation on the ground. Where I disagree is that a pedestrian-zone sign necessarily means every road after it should be tagged highway=pedestrian. In fact, the sign is located well before this segment, and the road immediately after it is mapped as highway=living_street, despite being under the same restriction. Cars are allowed to enter when their destination is within the area; only through traffic is prohibited, which is exactly what motor_vehicle=destination represents. So I don’t think this is about creating a “fictional map”, but about representing the actual road function and access restrictions as accurately as possible within OSM’s tagging limitations. |
|
| 190916079 | Sorry for misunderstanding, but the end it is not to accommodate my need. The sign says explicitly Průjezd zakázán ( 'no through traffic'), which is also applicable for other cars, not only taxi/ridesharing, and allows the cars to go there if it's the destination of the route. Also there is a tag of motor_vehicle=destination on the road which in combination with highway=pedestrian is not working for neither OSRM, Valhalla or Graph Hopper which are OSM official routing engine. My edit reflects the ground truth of the signs |
|
| 183063555 | Salut. Poti valida ca aceasta strada a fost redeschisa traficului? |