OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
174336678

It has been mapped properly, with name=* [1], why is this node [2] necessary?

[1] way/394436454

[2] node/13287326048

173741082

Ground truth from May 2023

173517358

*T148

There's TomTom's street car view but they're from 2017... and not yielding any positive results.

169218576

P.S. Still I believe "Jalan Raya" might not fit local_name

Pedantry: this however has a name signpost which is this one - https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jalan_Pintas_Semeling_1.jpg

I believe since it existed like probably 50 years plus and recently just got gazetted as a federal route... I don't think the current name fits up until here osm.org/go/4GouCpAcB-?m=

169218576

Many thanks for your reply.

I believe "Jalan Raya" is a bit too generic. I do commute through this specific route to go balik kampung sometimes and I can't find any signpost that mentions "Jalan Raya". So the north-south Federal Route 1 is not "Jalan Raya"?* What makes it not another "Jalan Raya"? That's why it's much easier when at least a (permissible, not copyrighted) source can be brought to the discussion.

Jalan Pasar is probably signposted - I'll check for it again (ground truth) when I go balik kampung again in the near future. If there's a road sign for it, or prominently displayed via addresses on business signs, it's all clear.

* "Jalan Alor Setar-Butterworth" is indeed in official documents but at least it appears on this road sign - this is taken by me: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Federal_Route_1_Jalan_Butterworth_Alor_Setar_sign_with_destinations_and_distances_to_them.jpg

169218576

Could you please respond to messages and/or discussions over here?

Lack of response might be the potential cause of getting reported to OpenStreetMap's Data Working Group, worse come to worst, a block to the account.

169218576

way/1336789763

"Jalan Raya" for real?

168476372

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Papan_tanda_Kampung_Baru_Sungai_Gurun.jpg

168396634

NBCT ni masalah sikit sebab papan tanda memang dalam bahasa Inggeris... tapi tak pasti la kalau dah ada papan tanda premis dah letak nama bahasa Melayu

167514032

I took this photo on Friday the 13th of June 2025

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Road_surface_marking_at_a_junction_state_route_K138.jpg

There are only painted marks on the road surface - no physical road dividers.

166803804

takde divider, lorong pun buat cat je https://github.com/GRABOSM/Grab-Data/issues/59#issuecomment-692530410

164110862

banyak jugak larangan U turn untuk kenderaan berat yang memang ada papan tanda (verifiable on the ground) kena delete satu satu...

162938594

way/285035549

Surprisingly there are Christians buried there as well...

162528955

Hi there.

Any reason why this is deleted? way/1018185663

162032327

Kenapa delete?

108963023

Faham, yang ada gambar tu kat sini: osm.org/go/4MDOyfCml--?m=

Tapi takde apa-apa gambar pulak kat sini osm.org/go/4MDL2teQ9--?m=

Tak berapa nak konfiden tapi kalau nak ubah ok je kot...

108963023

Memang kena confirm balik... kat Pasir Tumboh tu... takde gambar pulak.

108963023

Ohhhh tak, tak. Yang ni rupanya.

https://www.bing.com/maps?cp=6.091186~102.276295&lvl=17&dir=132.401&style=x&v=2&sV=1

https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/532431177
https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/532431177

108963023

Yang ni ke?

https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/42707889
https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/42707889

Fuh... berkurun tak pergi Kota Bharu. Bing StreetSide kalau gambar ambil tahun 2019 punya, tukar je terus.

161998318

Dari bulan 6 tahun lepas lagi... orang putih kata it is what it is...