Changeset: 77480264
Tagging of train protection systems in Belgium
Closed by JJJWegdam
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15492 en) |
---|---|
source | SPW(allonie) most recent aerial imagery; AIV Flanders 2013-2015 aerial imagery 10cm; AIV Flanders most recent aerial imagery |
Discussion
-
Comment from M!dgard
You made a grave error here: retagging railway=rail to railway=razed, instead of adding the train protection tags.
-
Comment from M!dgard
I reverted this changeset in https://osm.org/changeset/77636565. You may want to try again adding the TBL 1+ tags.
-
Comment from JJJWegdam
Apparently it is now common practise that we revert an entire changeset if not all changes are mentioned in the changeset description. Even more so that such a revert happens without any room for discussion.
-
Comment from M!dgard
Hi JJJWegdam, I wasn't criticizing the fact that you occasionally mark razed railways as such in your train protection changesets.
In this CS you marked entire lines that still exist as razed. That's why I reverted it.
-
Comment from JJJWegdam
This revert has been reverted:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/77641554Note to the author of 77636565:
please refer to
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Revert_scripts#Act_responsibly.21
and provide room for discussion before reverting a changeset -
Comment from JJJWegdam
To adress "In this CS you marked entire lines that still exist as razed. That's why I reverted it.":
Even then, I am certainly available and willing to repair mistakes. This is not possible if the changeset is reverted without notice
-
Comment from M!dgard
You removed at least these lines in error:
- between Aalter and Oostkamp,
- the entirity of Bruges yard,
- between Bruges and Blankenberge,
- all industrial lines in the port of Zeebrugge.This is kilometers upon kilometers of rail that's starting to vanish from the rendered tiles. Since I can't know when you will be able to fix it, this seemed substantial enough to warrant a revert.
Moreover, I could only see two correct changes in this changeset, so you'd have to revert everything manually anyway.
-
Comment from JJJWegdam
Repairing it right away
-
Comment from M!dgard
I did not use the scripts you mentioned so that page does not apply.
Ways (41-60 of 788)
- L.51 (294550083), v6
- L.51 (294550084), v6
- L.51 (294550085), v5
- L.51 (294550086), v6
- L.51 (294550087), v6
- L.51 (294550088), v4
- L.51 (294550089), v4
- L.51 (294550090), v4
- L.51A (294550091), v6
- L.51 (294550092), v4
- L.51 (294550093), v4
- L.51 (294550094), v5
- L.51 (294550095), v4
- L.51A (294550096), v6
- L.51 (294550097), v4
- L.51A (294550098), v6
- L.51 (294550099), v7
- L.51 (294550100), v8
- L.51 (294556103), v4
- L.51 (294556104), v4
Nodes (2)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |