Changeset: 75412694
harmonized similar values to shop=license_plates where it seemed clear that no much more general shop=sign is appropriate
Closed by schoschi
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15238 de) |
---|---|
source | website |
Discussion
-
Comment from Geste27
Hi schoschi,
eine Attribut-Vereinheitlichung ist eine gute Idee, hier gibt's wohl verschiedene Möglichkeiten, siehe: https://dict.leo.org/englisch-deutsch/Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen
Hattest Du das mit jemand besprochen?
Oder gibt es dazu einen wiki-Artikel?Schöne Grüsse
-
Comment from goedegazelle
I have to point out that "license_plates" is American English and not British.
-
Comment from schoschi
Hi @Geste27 and @goedegazelle, when I wanted to map a shop creating license plates, I found no no agreed/voted tag value in the wiki. Using taginfo, I discovered different wordings and each in multiple spellings - I just chose the most often used wording matching the "space replaced by underscore" spelling pattern. I was not aware "license plate" is American English. We may change to BE - I don't care, both is foreign language to me and the vast majority of people ;-)
-
Comment from goedegazelle
I can imagine the confusion. I used "number_plate" for a shop in my own town.
-
Comment from SK53
As @goedegazelle points out license plate is American English & in OSM we use British English, which is licence. There are different words which the Americans choose to spell in the same way. I suspect these may be better mapped as plain car_parts with an appropriate subtag (product perhaps), unless they are really common (100s of examples in DE for instance).
-
Comment from Nakaner
Hi schoschi,
this changeset is a mechanical edit. Where can I find the discussion of this mechanical edit as required by the Automated Edits Code of Conduct (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct)?
Mechanical edits should be discussed and documented in advance because they are a powerful tool to enforce one's personal view of a matter. Changing all occurrences of a tag will influence the decision of other mappers which tag to choose. Therefore, the Automated Edits Code of Conduct asks for a discussion in advance to ensure that the change is based on the consensus of the OSM community.
Best regards
Michael
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/75412694
-
Comment from schoschi
@all: As it turns out not to be a simple matter, I started a forum discussion at https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=765301
@SK53 Your post adds further spelling options. For tagging scheme, please see forum. Yes, such shops are common, I estimate 1000-2000 in Germany alone.
@Nakaner / Michael: No, this changeset was not automated but manual, i.e. I did manually check all occurrences and consolidated where appropriate; some nodes shall have had completely different tags which I corrected along the way.
The OSMCha Link is broken "Failed to load page 0" and login fails. What shall that page tell? -
Comment from JochenOSM
Reverted in change 78932248: There is still (11 weeks later) no consensus about harmonizing these values at all.
The original poster did not reply to the arguments and votes for "number_plate" in https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=67647 any more.
Therefore reverted change 75412694 to singular of previous value until there is a consensus about the tagging.
Ways (16)
- Schilder- von der Heyden (111749234), v8
- 184621264, v4
- STL-Busch (208428479), v5
- Auto-Schilder (260623518), v4
- Nummernschilder (335741417), v4
- 421606673, v2
- 441937377, v2
- 441937378, v2
- 441937379, v2
- 441937380, v2
- 441937381, v2
- 441937382, v2
- 441937383, v2
- Kroschke Autoschilder (445172164), v3
- 466965522, v2
- 466965523, v2
Nodes (1-20 of 32)
- 1
- 2
- Kfz-Schilder (335484601), v6
- Autoschilder (673930695), v5
- 736901451, v2
- 736901455, v4
- Astorga (1360164543), v3
- Maqalf signs & plates (1398452428), v3
- 1831649808, v4
- Kfz-Schilder (2661436663), v3
- 2861787471, v6
- Worldplak (3359424205), v2
- Schilderstelle (3363207854), v4
- 3399940769, v4
- EHA Autoschilder GmbH - Niederlassung Lüdenscheid (MK) (3491959706), v7
- Schilder-von der Heyden GmbH - Niederlassung Lüdenscheid (3491961921), v9
- Autoschilder (3554579888), v4
- AB Autoschilder (3705760326), v4
- Autoschilder Kürzinger (3966478760), v3
- Autoschilder Kroschke (4014991150), v4
- Autoschilder Pickard (4014991152), v4
- Autoschilder Peter Häfele (4352748439), v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |