Changeset: 62272284
changed highway tag in CBD (Bxl Nord) from residential to tertiary or service road. (no residential on these roads and some are major boulevard or avenue).
Closed by Anakil
Tags
changesets_count | 1992 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.11.1 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | AGIV Flanders most recent aerial imagery |
locale | fr |
Discussion
-
Comment from bxl-forever
Hello,
I hadn’t noticed this changeset until today.
highway=service looks to me as something very specific (driveways, short road connectors, delivery alleys…). Along Simón Bolívar, the small roads on the side are used to park vehicles, and to connect adjacent office buildings → wouldn’t highway=residential make sense anyway, despite there are "technically" no residents?
Didn’t find conclusive evidence on the wiki.
What do you think? -
Comment from Anakil
Hi,
It is not residential because the definition is relatively strict to include residential building along the "residential" road in OSM. We had a similar discussion about this on the riot chat i think, and multiple people told that it should be in a residential area (landuse) and with multiple residential buildings to be "residential road" (but we could re-ask it ^^). So it could either be unclassified or service road. At this time i choose service, but it could be changed to unclassified. But in this case, i think that these small portion are not the main driving parts, and should only be used for access to the building, parking or to the bus stops, ... So to me, it is more a service road than a "normal - connection" road (but that's my opinion ahah). I though as "how do i map road in a parking or in a bus station, as it is service road there, i choose the same classification here. -
Comment from bxl-forever
OK, I get your point. Maybe we’d keep highway=service anyway.
- Boulevard du Roi Albert II - Koning Albert II-laan (15243839), v24
- Boulevard du Roi Albert II - Koning Albert II-laan (32759215), v6
- Boulevard du Roi Albert II - Koning Albert II-laan (335622703), v4
- Boulevard Simon Bolivar - Simon Bolivarlaan (15243879), v15
- Boulevard Simon Bolivar - Simon Bolivarlaan (41220239), v6
- Chaussée d'Anvers - Antwerpsesteenweg (404614541), v3
- Chaussée d'Anvers - Antwerpsesteenweg (11479945), v17
- Boulevard Simon Bolivar - Simon Bolivarlaan (404614542), v5
- Boulevard Simon Bolivar - Simon Bolivarlaan (11480160), v10
- Boulevard Simon Bolivar - Simon Bolivarlaan (404614544), v4
- Avenue de l'Héliport - Helihavenlaan (404614878), v2
- Avenue de l'Héliport - Helihavenlaan (355239247), v4
- Rue Willem De Mol - Willem De Molstraat (22262329), v5
- Boulevard du Roi Albert II - Koning Albert II-laan (238860833), v6
- Rue Rogier - Rogierstraat (85604352), v6
- Rue Rogier - Rogierstraat (419562687), v4
- Boulevard du Roi Albert II - Koning Albert II-laan (31108375), v9
- Boulevard du Roi Albert II - Koning Albert II-laan (32759223), v5
- Place Solvay - Solvayplein (15897090), v9
- Place Solvay - Solvayplein (76816002), v9
Relations (1)
Nodes (1)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |