Changeset: 57692479
Most often used names are now the main name, moved the rest to the alt_name, following general usage and Wikipedia
Closed by Robin van der Vliet
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (13576 en) |
---|---|
source | knowledge |
Discussion
-
Comment from SK53
I realise these changes are relatively minor, perhaps that could be expressed in the changeset comment. Changes to several country nodes at once is often a sign of inappropriate edits.
Also, by the way, wikipedia is not usually an admissible source for edits to OpenStreetMap data: it allows extensive use of copyright sources and data compilations which would not be admissible directly in OSM.
-
Comment from Robin van der Vliet
Esperanto country names for some countries traditionally end in -ujo. In modern general language usage this suffix is replaced by -io. I replaced it everywhere manually based on my own knowledge of Esperanto. I didn't use Wikipedia as a source, I used it as a way to show to other people that the country names ending with -io exist and are used by the majority.
-
Comment from SK53
Thanks: having spent a few minutes looking at the changes I suspected this was the case. In this case a more precise changeset comment would have saved us both the effort of these comments.
-
Comment from ☆Finvenkulo
Kial vi ŝanĝis tion? Oni jam multe skribis pri sistemoj de land-nomoj: http://bonalingvo.net/index.php/Landonomoj_en_Esperanto:_facile_kaj_logike
La sistemo kun -uj- estas pli Fundamenta kaj pli logika ol la sistemo kun kvazaŭsufikso -i-.Estas sensence malsimpligi la lingvon kaj sekvi la plejparton da homoj. -
Comment from Robin van der Vliet
Mi prifajfas logikecon. OSM sekvu la ĝeneralan lingvouzadon. Esperanto estas vivanta kaj praktike uzata lingvo, ĝi ne estas ia teorio.
- O'zbekiston (424317428), v74
- Danmark (432424968), v65
- Suomi (432424981), v43
- საქართველო (432424985), v49
- Ελλάδα (432424989), v55
- Latvija (432425019), v70
- Монгол Улс (432425040), v59
- Polska (432425060), v77
- România (432425064), v64
- Slovensko (432425079), v66
- 臺灣 (432425099), v91
- ประเทศไทย (437146363), v61
- Аҧсны - Абхазия (466507355), v40
- United Kingdom (838090640), v49
- France (1363947712), v21
- Ireland (1420871007), v30
- Schweiz, Suisse, Svizzera, Svizra (1504546320), v19
- Україна (1648342273), v15
- Deutschland (1683325355), v18
- België - Belgique - Belgien (1684793666), v23
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |