Changeset: 135096633
Revert ChrisBessert blasting through Michigan and changing highways again
Closed by emersonveenstra
Tags
created_by | reverter_plugin/36043;JOSM/1.5 (18700 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from Minh Nguyen
Hi, is “OLD 31” signposted anywhere? This changeset seems to have introduced ref=OLD 31 as an alternative to old_ref=US 31, unless I’m misreading the history.
-
Comment from emersonveenstra
it was a straight revert, so it shouldn't have added anything new. Do you have a link to a way where it wasn't there before?
-
Comment from Minh Nguyen
I think every way in this changeset was affected, for example: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1119506496
-
Comment from Minh Nguyen
Looking at the history, you weren’t responsible for adding the tag originally, but your revert effectively added it back in. Please be careful using the reverter plugin; sometimes the mapper you’re reverting says they’re only changing one thing, but in fact they’re changing a lot of stuff that you might not disagree with (such as the relations in this changeset).
-
Comment from emersonveenstra
Sure, but that's assuming that it was incorrectly added in the first place, which is something i'm not able to verify. My thought process was that if it is incorrect, then someone with local knowledge would come along and fix it.
-
Comment from Minh Nguyen
I’m not sure that’s fair. If you only disagreed with the highway classification changes, you should’ve only undone those changes without all the others, unless you had reason to believe you were dealing with vandalism, fiction, a copyright violation, or some other bad-faith edit. The revert plugin is convenient but not always the right tool for addressing problems in the database.
-
Comment from emersonveenstra
You're right, I looked back and didn't realize how many other changes there were. I've gone through and undid all the changes not related to the classification
-
Comment from Minh Nguyen
Thank you!
- Whitehall Road (1119506484), v5
- 1st Street (1119506488), v4
- 1st Street (1119506489), v4
- South Oceana Drive (1119506490), v4
- South State Street (1119506491), v4
- North State Street (1119506492), v4
- North State Street (1119506493), v4
- North State Street (1119506495), v4
- South Oceana Drive (1119506496), v4
- North Oceana Drive (1119506497), v4
- North Oceana Drive (1119506498), v4
- North Oceana Drive (1119506499), v4
- South State Street (1119747202), v6
- South State Street (1119747203), v6
- South State Street (1119747205), v6
- Northland Drive (1119747206), v6
- Northland Drive (1119762483), v6
- South Main Street (1119762484), v6
- Northland Drive (1119762490), v6
- Federal Road (1119762494), v6
- SMART 851: Lone Pine => Wayne State University => Downtown Detroit (7798635), v71
- SMART 851: Downtown Detroit => Wayne State University => Lone Pine Road via WSU (7798636), v57
- 830 NB: Trenton => Downtown (7798637), v32
- 830 SB: Downtown => Trenton (7798638), v38
- 160 SB: Dearborn TC => Trenton (7798834), v29
- 160 NB: Trenton => Dearborn TC (7798836), v36
- 89 SB: Grand Blvd => Outer Dr (7798862), v28
- 08 WB: Mack => Telegraph (7798981), v23
- 08 EB: Telegraph => Mack (7798982), v29
- 9473646, v3
- East Fulton (9751990), v12
- East Leonard (9757271), v15
- GRCC (9760176), v8
- 10044576, v3
- 10044577, v3
- 10067258, v3
- 10067261, v3
- Paterson (12088626), v4
- Butternut/136th (12276885), v11
- Twilight North (12278597), v6
10822991835, v210822991836, v210822991837, v210822991838, v210823109917, v210823109918, v210823109919, v210823109920, v210823109921, v210823109922, v210823109923, v210823109924, v210823109925, v210823109926, v210823109927, v210823109928, v210823109929, v210823109930, v210823109931, v210823109932, v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |