Changeset: 105741063
Added buildings, addresses and other details #ukqp
Closed by drnoble
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (17428 SVN en_GB) |
---|---|
hashtags | #ukqp |
source | survey; Bing; ESRI; INSPIRE Land Registry Polygons; Mapillary; |
Discussion
-
Comment from DarkDays
Hey, I don't think you should be adding disused:shop=* and shop=vacant on the same node. Just disused:shop=* is enough.
While both identity an empty store front, having both can lead to shop=* being updated with disused:shop=* not getting removed.
-
Comment from DarkDays
By chance, the next one I looked at:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/1977957768
Just looking at the current OSM data there is no way to identify which is correct, is it a disused shoe shop, or a in use book shop.
Looking at the history we can obviously see it's a book shop, but data consumers can't.
-
Comment from drnoble
Hi, sorry for not replying on this, just saw it again when clearing through old emails.
I take your point that adding both tags might not be clear for data consumers. I think perhaps just using shop=vacant is better, as someone could add shop=something without realising there is a disused:shop=something tag. The old value will be there in the history, but is probably not that interesting for data consumers to know what the previous use was.
Cheers, Donald
- 949837676, v1
- 949837677, v1
- 949837678, v1
- 949837679, v1
- 949837680, v1
- 949837681, v1
- 949837682, v1
- 949837683, v1
- 949837684, v1
- 949837685, v1
- 949837686, v1
- 949837687, v1
- 949837688, v1
- Columba Terrace (949837689), v1
- 949837690, v1
- 949837691, v1
- 949837692, v1
- 949837693, v1
- 949837694, v1
- 949837695, v1
- 8793018794, v1
- 8793018795, v1
- 8793018796, v1
- 8793018797, v1
- 8793018798, v1
- 8793018799, v1
- 8793018800, v1
- 8793018801, v1
- 8793018802, v1
- 8793018803, v1
- 8793018804, v1
- 8793018805, v1
- 8793018806, v1
- Chapel House Arts (8793018807), v1
- Fused and Light (8793018808), v1
- 8793018809, v1
- 8793018810, v1
- 8793018811, v1
- 8793018812, v1
- 8793018813, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |