Changeset: 130534557
General cleanup of access tags on footways and paths (removing most obvious implicit tags such as foot=yes, bicycle=no or horse=no on ordinary footways)
Closed by bxl-forever
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18583 en) |
---|---|
source | UrbIS 2021 aerial imagery |
Discussion
-
Comment from ghia
From cartographers point of view, this is a nice clean-up. For the ordinary map user, this makes the access rules in the forest unclear. Therefore it is better to reverse this to the explicit rules: path/track foot, bike, horse: yes/no
The paths are also signed in this way with pictograms for their access on foot, bike or horse.
See also https://www.zonienwoud.be/ceci-nest-pas-un-bospad/
Salutations, Gerard -
Comment from bxl-forever
Hello,
Can you please provide an example of a forest path where the current tagging made it unclear.
This changeset did not change current access values, it only removed duplicate values. For instance, in OSM we do not say "this is a motorway and I tell you that cars mays use it and that bicycles may not", we just say "this is a motorway", when default rules apply.
The standard for Belgium is here:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/OSM_tags_for_routing/Access_restrictions#Belgium
Most routing apps (OsmAnd, GraphHopper, brouter) honour these default access values, and the main map will render paths normally.Very importantly: this changeset did not modify anything about paths where some modes of transport would be prohibited. If a path was already tagged as private or just forbidden, I did not change that, in the same way that I kept *restrictions* when they existed (for instance if a highway=path is forbidden to horse riders, I kept horse=no).
Were it to be an issue here, i.e. that I granted access by mistake, I would gladly fix it. But please provide an example, if any.
- 24452484, v4
- 24452565, v3
- 24452566, v3
- 24503690, v8
- 24507688, v7
- 24518864, v4
- 26616830, v9
- 27838600, v13
- 27924600, v5
- Sentier de la Cambre - Ter Kamerenvoetpad (27924668), v15
- Sentier des Maianthèmes - Dalkruidenpad (27924672), v10
- 29995078, v7
- 30278197, v4
- 30374774, v3
- 30374782, v3
- 30639593, v8
- 31613919, v8
- 31614011, v4
- 31614013, v5
- 31614014, v6
- 408990402, v9
- 408990413, v4
- 472236878, v3
- 473520058, v6
- 563919908, v5
- 586749681, v3
- 1150846611, v3
- 1347691540, v3
- 1347691542, v3
- 1708372675, v2
- 1708372695, v5
- 2288193461, v8
- 2288228979, v5
- 2475438323, v5
- 2503030985, v10
- 2907753652, v4
- 3062903115, v7
- 3068457934, v3
- 3068457961, v3
- 3068457963, v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |