mrpulley's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 116519029 | over 2 years ago | Also, has there been a formal request directly to OSM 'behind the scenes' from NPWS regarding these paths, that I am not aware of? |
| 116519029 | over 2 years ago | It's probably better to have something present on OSM, rather than deleting it. Otherwise, someone else could come along later and add it back in, not knowing there's been an issue. If the path has been formally closed, then access=no is an alternate tag to use. (This was used in a similar situation last year in another national park, when a new user deleted a path without discussion.) This might need another survey to clarify. |
| 137773356 | over 2 years ago | Just checking - is this based on a survey of the tracks? If the tracks are still visible, it might be better to leave the ways in, possibly with alteration of the tagging (depending on the current status of the tracks). See also discussion at changeset changeset/116519029 which concerns earlier edits to these ways. |
| 140660737 | over 2 years ago | Just checking - is this based on a survey of the tracks? If the tracks are still visible, it might be better to leave the ways in, possibly with alteration of the tagging (depending on the current status of the tracks). See also discussion at changeset changeset/116519029 which concerns earlier edits to these ways. |
| 116519029 | over 2 years ago | Were those tracks officially closed, or are they still informal? I had thought the consensus was to leave the path on OSM, marked as informal=yes. If it has been recently closed, might be better to leave it in, marked as abandoned:highway=* or disused:highway=* (otherwise someone might come along later and add it back in). (I'm too far away to go back there to re-survey in-person.) |
| 135332632 | over 2 years ago | Just letting you know that I've reverted this changeset. There is no new Orange East Station or associated new roadways next to James Sheahan High (I checked this yesterday). changeset/137194115 |
| 137194115 | over 2 years ago | Reversion of changeset changeset/135332632 |
| 122855119 | over 3 years ago | Just wondering what the note you added is for. You've added the note "Turn restriction needs one via way" to these relations, however all 4 of them already have a via way in them. Am I missing something? |
| 124166942 | over 3 years ago | Just letting you know that I've unconnected Dairy Creek Road from the Mitchell Highway. This section of road was closed when the new intersection for the Southern Feeder Road was opened. |
| 49976873 | over 3 years ago | Just letting you know that I've deleted this campsite, as it's not the name of the campsite. I've incorporated the node into the way marking the boundary of the actual campsite. |
| 12158034 | over 3 years ago | Just letting you know that your 'test' edits here have been removed - one was already removed, I removed the other last night. |
| 116519029 | over 3 years ago | I reviewed these ways a month ago - have just uploaded the change now (changeset/119854924) - path near cliff is there, so I've marked it as informal=yes. I found traces of the one further from the cliff, but with the recent heavy rains the grass was very long, so I couldn't do a complete survey - I've marked it as informal=yes, trail_visibility=bad. |
| 119715592 | over 3 years ago | Oops - now fixed changeset/119733440 - I've also added a level tag to way/860007355 - that will stop the Validator picking up an 'error' in future. |
| 81151064 | almost 4 years ago | I've just added a comment to changeset/116520175 |
| 116520175 | almost 4 years ago | These ways definitely exist (the fire trail and the access to some private houses): 238041069, 773692685, 773692684, 347707476. The short trail 439443961 and the short stairway 773692681 definitely exist. The remaining way/347707596 was there on survey in early 2020. Just looked at the National Parks web site - this path is now listed as closed. |
| 116519029 | almost 4 years ago | Regarding the two deleted ways - I had been thinking about deleting them when I was there three years ago (changeset/63140199) but left them alone. I didn't see those tracks at the time, but left them in case I had missed them. |
| 63140199 | almost 4 years ago | Regarding the two deleted ways - I had been thinking about deleting them when I was there three years ago (changeset/63140199) but left them alone. I didn't see those tracks at the time, but left them in case I had missed them. |
| 81494743 | over 4 years ago | No idea how that tag got there! I've just removed it - thanks. changeset/110140060 |
| 108650168 | over 4 years ago | Just letting you know that somehow you deleted the highway tag for Browns Creek Road way/43048463 - I spotted this when updating an edit last night, so I've fixed this for you this morning. |
| 96794885 | almost 5 years ago | Just letting you know that these new roads are open. I surveyed them recently, and didn't know you had added them until I was uploading my edits. |