mapbear66's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 181852828 | The name of Mill Burn is the only name in current common usage. Your source is bogus as it's an old reference, not a guide to current names.
|
|
| 181841535 | Your sources used for the change of name are inappropriate, being ancient names not at all current or well known. |
|
| 181841535 | And Torr Achilty... |
|
| 181841535 | And Loch Achanalt... |
|
| 181841535 | Why have you changed the name tag of Loch Garve to Loch Gairbh? - that's not what it is known as Why are you doing this? |
|
| 181206312 | On a number places of you had deleted the well known name and replaced it with gaelic, but not put the existing name in name:en. But that is immaterial. Do not repeat that changeset as it's a huge edit without proper scrutiny or verifiable sources. You have been inappropriately changing well known names for gaelic where it is not used. You obviously have an agenda to replace all name tags in Scotland with Gaelic even where it is not routinely used - i.e. the ground truth, which is not in the interest of OpenStreetMap. Who are you? |
|
| 178003200 | If you have verifiable sources feel free to update it... but pick one language not both. Verifiable sources, something that any other mapper would be able to look at, Gaelic only road signs, house, business, school names etc. |
|
| 175740817 | I see that it is not just a few names you have changed, it's all over Skye. Please see this page on the OSM wiki: osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#Scotland
Thanks. |
|
| 175740817 | Hi. I am that renderer wondering about "en - gd" in the name tag. I'd expect one or the other not both. It should be what it's mostly known as. |
|
| 171309354 | That's more plausible. Thank you. |
|
| 169784436 | For the avoidance of doubt, tracks like this: way/1396568307#map=19/51.948253/-8.439933&layers=P and this is the track I meant to link to originally: |
|
| 169784436 | Hi,
Thanks. |
|
| 169784436 | Tracks: you should not be mapping things for routing, much like not mapping for a renderer. Your tracks cannot be verified by someone else as they don't exist on the ground. See osm.wiki/Good_practice#Map_what's_on_the_ground for useful info on this. Please review those you have put in. Hedges vs scrub. It's tricky, and sometimes controversial whether a narrow strip is a barrier=? or area of scrub, trees, etc. I prefer a barrier, but wont push my bias here. |
|
| 169784436 | Hi there. I really like much of the mapping you've been doing in this area but have an observation. Many of these tracks you have been putting in around the edge of fields don't appear to be on aerial photography, Bing or ESRI. I was wondering your source for the tracks? Or whether you've been a bit overly keen on interpreting mowing or ploughing marks as tracks? Another was you've marked some boundaries between fields as scrub. I'd expect these to be barrier=hedge as scrub is really for larger areas? Thanks. |
|
| 167462584 | Hi, Did you mean to delete the path from near Carn na Criche round the top of the crags of Garbh Choire Mor to Sgurr an Lochan Uaine... Thanks. |
|
| 152285582 | Hi,
Thanks. |
|
| 164131441 | No bother. It helps to know relations are around, and some editors are set up better to show them.
|
|
| 164131441 | Hi. The name "Speyside Way" should not be on the constituent paths. Some paths may have their own names. Speyside Way is already, correctly, a route relation. Please remove the erroneous name tags. |
|
| 161741713 | Hi,
|
|
| 145814835 | We don't really use fell in Scotland. And whilst I kinda object to our moors having to be tagged as heath, it is heather moorland. So that's the accepted tag. Tundra seems an odd tag to use. It's neither cold, nor high. The closest we have to the general idea of tundra is the Cairngorm plateaux. Anyway, either reconsider, or if you are done with the area I can take it over. I just didn't want to tread on your toes. |