"Was recently renovated into apartments"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-12-14T02:16:23Z
POI name: St John's Methodist Church
POI types: building amenity-place_of_worship-christian
#organicmaps android 2025.12.16-16-FDroid

"The post office closed down a few weeks ago, I visited personally"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-12-14T02:16:23Z
POI name: St Johns Post Office
POI types: amenity-post_office
#organicmaps android 2025.12.16-16-FDroid