Hi Zh9567, thank you so much for your continuous hard work and dedication to updating the map. I really appreciate how closely you've been monitoring the Shah Alam Line — your efforts are making the infrastructure details look incredibly complete!

I just wanted to gently share a small detail regarding the station tags based on the OSM wiki guidelines. Usually, the community prefers to keep the construction: lifecycle prefix (like construction:railway=station) until the line officially opens for revenue service. The main worry is that third-party routing apps might pull the active tags too early and accidentally navigate the public into closed construction sites, which could be quite dangerous. Would it be okay if you revert them to the construction status for the time being just to be safe and kindly wait for the official announcement?

You've really done an amazing job mapping out the alignment and station structures so far, and your contributions are super valuable to the local Malaysian mapping community. Let's definitely coordinate and celebrate by activating all these tags together the moment the official launch day arrives! Thanks again for all your amazing effort.

Hi, for the bus stop like Psrn Suadamai, the place for network should be either MRT feeder or Smart Selangor, the route code should be at other field, see more at

osm.wiki/Bus_routes_in_Klang_Valley

After checking, these area are not official rest area, so these area can be separately mapped as a petrol/retail area

referring to this

way/764459908/history#map=19/3.235226/101.690349

you may change it, tq

Hi kucai, thanks for the comment. Since this changeset is from 6 years ago, I’m not sure which specific sign or area you are referring to. Could you clarify the exact location or coordinates? As it’s been quite a long time, the ground reality may have changed or the sign might have been removed since then. Feel free to update it if you have the latest info!

Hi, I think they bus location for MSC is misplaced, please check

Or highway=unclassified if applied

Hi, we don't use living_street attributes in Malaysia, if residential area should stick with highway=residential, thank you.

Hi, please explain why you are adding non-Malaysian local name places in Pandan Perdana.

The Bukit chagar is not operational station yet, should put it as construction station not railway station

Hii, please do not put the station tag for station that are under construction

Hii, please do not put the trant station tag for station that are still under construction

Hi, this is not a station yet

Hi, I don't think it's an existing station yet, please make it as construction building and station

It should be a watson

Hi, Bandar Serenia shouldn't be ref=10 I think

Hi thank you for adding new bus services in OSM, kindly request also update for the list of bus route for monitoring and tracking
osm.wiki/Bus_routes_in_Klang_Valley

Thank you

osm.wiki/Bus_routes_in_Klang_Valley
Hi, can you please update in this page for all the new bus stops as well, thank you.

Kepada pengguna petajalanterbuka,

Terima kasih atas sumbangan anda dalam mengemaskini data OpenStreetMap.

Saya ingin mencadangkan agar nama asal "Jalan Jinjang Permai 9" dalam Bahasa Inggeris tidak dipadamkan sepenuhnya daripada data. Sebaliknya, adalah lebih sesuai sekiranya nama tersebut disimpan di dalam tag old_name=* sebagai rujukan sejarah dan kemudahan pengguna lain.

Untuk makluman, berdasarkan laporan oleh DBKL sekitar tahun 2007-2008, memang terdapat penukaran rasmi nama-nama jalan di kawasan Jinjang kepada versi Bahasa Malaysia, seperti yang direkodkan dalam sumber berikut:
https://aarvidi.wordpress.com/2008/02/11/87-roads-in-jinjang-get-new-names-to-dignify-bahasa-malaysia/

https://b.cari.com.my/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=103786&page=5

Walau bagaimanapun, realitinya adalah ramai penduduk tempatan, serta dokumen rasmi seperti kad pengenalan, bil utiliti dan surat-menyurat, masih menggunakan nama lama. Oleh itu, penyimpanan nama asal sebagai old_name=* akan membantu mengekalkan rujukan yang relevan, sekali gus memudahkan pengguna yang mencari lokasi berdasarkan nama lama.

Sekian, terima kasih atas perhatian dan kerjasama anda.

Yang benar,
angys

Kepada pengguna petajalanterbuka,

Terima kasih atas sumbangan anda dalam mengemaskini data OpenStreetMap.

Saya ingin mencadangkan agar nama asal "Jalan Jinjang Indah 9" dalam Bahasa Inggeris tidak dipadamkan sepenuhnya daripada data. Sebaliknya, adalah lebih sesuai sekiranya nama tersebut disimpan di dalam tag old_name=* sebagai rujukan sejarah dan kemudahan pengguna lain.

Untuk makluman, berdasarkan laporan oleh DBKL sekitar tahun 2007-2008, memang terdapat penukaran rasmi nama-nama jalan di kawasan Jinjang kepada versi Bahasa Malaysia, seperti yang direkodkan dalam sumber berikut:
https://aarvidi.wordpress.com/2008/02/11/87-roads-in-jinjang-get-new-names-to-dignify-bahasa-malaysia/

https://b.cari.com.my/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=103786&page=5

Walau bagaimanapun, realitinya adalah ramai penduduk tempatan, serta dokumen rasmi seperti kad pengenalan, bil utiliti dan surat-menyurat, masih menggunakan nama lama. Oleh itu, penyimpanan nama asal sebagai old_name=* akan membantu mengekalkan rujukan yang relevan, sekali gus memudahkan pengguna yang mencari lokasi berdasarkan nama lama.

Sekian, terima kasih atas perhatian dan kerjasama anda.

Yang benar,
angys

Hi, can you explain the addition of the "Flooded Area" commercial area in OSM editors? Is it a testing