OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
107457508 over 4 years ago

Hi Robert. Afraid I think I've duplicated the building and accidentally retained the postcode from another location. Just checked this against onspd and have corrected it. I'm hoping to run a few more checks on other edits of mine soon to ensure I haven't repeated these elsewhere.

101814631 almost 5 years ago

Hi Adlid! Sorry about that, I'm new to mapping here and more used to areas with sparse data. I'll have to revisit this in a few days on my pc and use the method you mention, thanks for the info. Best, zendesk.

101150579 almost 5 years ago

Resolved, thanks for pointing it out!

90774360 over 5 years ago

https://osmhv.openstreetmap.de/changeset.jsp?id=91189802+ shows removal of terraces and replacement

90774360 over 5 years ago

Hi FinB2000. I appreciate your amendments. Can I also recommend reverting 91189802 and 90651430 as these also cover the same issue of building deletions.

90774360 over 5 years ago

Also 90848453

90848453 over 5 years ago

Deletions

90824237 over 5 years ago

Deletions

90710844 over 5 years ago

Deletions

90774360 over 5 years ago

My concerns also lie with changesets 90824237 and 90710844. I would really appreciate it if you would revert these changes and discuss next steps with me first.

90774360 over 5 years ago

Hi FinB2000. This is not about whether the edits are intentional. Firstly the content you removed was based on days of extensive surveying performed by myself and as a courtesy you should have discussed it before removing en masse. Secondly, your edits in my opinion do not reflect the nature of the buildings on the ground. Your response does not seem to engage with this issue at all and I'm concerned you haven't responded to my comments. Ultimately OSM is based on consensus and right now having spoken with the IRC Talk-GB group the response has been that your edit should be reverted. Please appreciate I am not arguing with you, I am merely concerned that you have removed a lot of my hard work without even trying to talk it over.

90774360 over 5 years ago

I'm also incredibly concerned you have made these deletions without consulting me or anyone else.

90774360 over 5 years ago

Hi FinB2000 - are you sure this is a wise edit? All of these structures are separate buildings and while editing the geometry as you've done provides one clean structure, it removes the precision with which units are identified. As some are historic buildings it seems to be it is preferable to keep them individually, and their geometry as of previous edits was not in any way 'wrong'? Furthermore your edits to the bus station seem incorrect as they have removed individual bus lanes. Good practice I've seen elsewhere is to identify bus platforms with each lane.

75606133 about 6 years ago

No worries, Fin. Yes I hope to get around to some housing areas soon.