OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
116554564 almost 4 years ago

Hey Kovoschiz, after taking a second look I agree that we should preserve pedestrian routing here. Thank you for reaching out to me and making the edit!
TrueWeast

93869346 over 4 years ago

Hej osmviborg. Jeg set at du har opdateret færgeterminalet i Aarhus Bugt. Jeg har lavet små opdater at en nær vej, og har spørgasmål hvis der er mere ændrer i nærheden.
Tak, Trueweast

Hello osmviborg, I noticed you updated the data for the ferry terminal in Aarhus Bugt. I made a small update to the highway modeling near the ferry terminals, and I am curious if there are any further updates to this area.
Thanks, TrueWeast

77656996 over 4 years ago

¡Hola Challenger1007! Me di cuenta que agregó un nodo de ‘amenity=place_of_worship’ aquí (node/7015837696) y aceras con las palabras “Ave Maria Auxiliadora” cerca de ellas. El OSM Wiki para “highway=footway” (highway=footway) dice que esta etiqueta es usada para vías menores que son utilizadas mayormente o exclusivamente por peatones. Por lo que puedo entender, estas letras no parecen ser en aceras, y espero encontrar una etiqueta mejor para describirlas - quizás, algo que describe el material del que están hechas. Tiene usted algo tipo de conocimiento local sobre este sitio? Parece que man_made=geoglyph seria una etiqueta apropiada. ¿Cual es su opinión acerca de esto?

96441476 over 4 years ago

Thank you for your response, I have made the edits. changeset/103719428

96441476 over 4 years ago

Hey angys,

I noticed here that you reclassified this primary to tertiary (way/750641368), and I am curious what you might know about the highways in this area. It seems as if the current primary is built to handle more traffic, but based on aerial imagery at this eastern intersection (osm.org/#map=20/2.3105665561010587/102.4274341022943), it appears westbound traffic must use this tertiary. Also, the `ref=M2` follows the primary east and west until it meets this tertiary. Do you know why the `ref=M2` tag exists along the tertiary and not on the primary highway immediately north of it? Is it possible both highways are part of the M2, and both highways should be considered primary?

Looking forward to hearing from you,

TrueWeast

93487510 about 5 years ago

Hello,

I noticed you were changing the “ref” value of the М-7 near Шелокша. Did you consider the “loc_ref” or “reg_ref” tags for these additions to the map? Using these tags will provide additional detail, without removing the “ref=М-7,” which appears to be valid based on this wiki page (osm.wiki/RU:Россия/Автодороги#Автомобильные_дороги_общего_пользования_федерального_значения). Another option would be to separate these refs by semicolon (;), such as “ref=М-7;22К-0098.” These methods allow both refs to be accounted for on the same way.

For more information about ref tags and their usage, please see ref=*

Let me know if you have any questions,
TrueWeast

93343170 about 5 years ago

Hey tutaaa,

I noticed that you reclassified the A-121 recently. Do you know if there are motorway begins/ends signs at the entrance and exits of the A-121 now? Based on osm.wiki/RU:Key:highway, motorways require such signage on the ground, and all the recent ground-level imagery I have found does not confirm a motorway begins/ends at these locations (osm.org/#map=16/60.0890/30.3758) , (osm.org/#map=16/60.6730/30.0140). Such an edit typically requires some form of ground-level truth and given that you only cited Maxar for this edit, I would like to ask what ground-level confirmation did you use?
Kindest regards,

TrueWeast

92368242 about 5 years ago

This is an interesting interpretation of how highway classifications are utilized at junctions. This scheme would be unique to Hong Kong as I haven't seen this in other countries. If this is the desire of the Hong Kong community to visualize junctions this way, it would benefit the community to discuss on discord then document on the OSM Wiki.

Thanks,
TrueWeast

92368242 about 5 years ago

Hey Kovoschiz, I classified these ways as primary to keep a consistent classification through the intersection. Based on global trends, this is the most common practice. I understand your logic, but I did not see anything related to this modeling policy on the Hong Kong Roads wiki (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong/Transport/Road). Is there any documentation I am missing?

Thanks,

TrueWeast

89875031 over 5 years ago

Hey Kovoschiz,

Thanks for the review and feedback!
TrueWeast