NM$L's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 192223747 | Cannot read the purpose from the changeset. |
|
| 192164727 | You mentioned 2005 Agreement on Political Parameters and Guiding Principles. Please mind that OSM does not represent such political claim, especially when the real final boundary has not been decided. |
|
| 192164727 | Thank you. Chinese claim territory has already mapped on OSM as a disputed area, the same as the relation of Aksai Chin of Indian claim. But for the boundary tagging as "administrative", or the rendered one, it should be the de-facto line. Although this area is not align with the watershed or terrain, it is still patrolled by both sides. According to On the Ground rule, as you said, the map should reflect this situation. There are too many boundaries, confirmed or disputed, in the world that are not align with terrains. It's a normal phenomenon, especially for there the two fishtails and are near Taksing where Mc. Line did not give you a clear boundary. Thus, I still recommend to reflect the on-the-ground fact. |
|
| 192164727 | ||
| 192164727 | And also I found that in your following changeset, you deleted the fishtail relation, whichmay not be good.
Such area has necessary to exist. |
|
| 192164727 | Typo: 6km away from the Mc. Line |
|
| 192164727 | Thank you for replying and agreeing that OSM follows the On the Ground, i.e. de-facto rule. India has outposts about 6mk away from the Mc. Line, or the Indian claim boundary, but there currently is not any permanent infrastructure in this area for both sides as I know. China also reports their patrolling regularly, so it is not India exclusive patrolling. Before February 2026, the boundary on OSM of two fishtails were totally are totally stable, and the fishtail boundary has many years of history. In February, there was someone changing the boundary situation at that time. So, after months when I recall this, I reverted it. Thank you so much for being willing to discuss this. We all know that the CN-IN LAC is quite complicated right now, and there are still many uninhabited areas with unclear boundaries. I've always wanted to suggest but did not find a chance that, for such areas without permanent facilities, where both sides conduct overlapping patrols, we may include these areas under the relationship for both sides at the same time, just like what people do on OSM for Crimea region between Ukraine and Russia. I don't know how do you, and even Indian community think about it? |
|
| 192164727 | Hi, OSM follows de-facto for disputed area.
|
|
| 191973943 | 注意到您删除了
请还原该公园,谢谢 |
|
| 183797575 | 来源请求? |
|
| 177433223 | Hi, OSM follows the on-the-ground principle, please do not delete existing things, add fake features, and change main name tags which should be in the language the actual controlling country are using. Your changesets from 177430054 to this are reverted. |
|
| 173954541 | Hi. Could you please explain why you moved the place label of Tsona? |
|
| 172523795 | Vietnam is claiming ✔
China is controlling these island de-facto, no matter who is legal. Similarly, there are islands controlled by Vietnam southern these islands which are mapped in Vietnamese. btw OSM is not for LLM contents. |
|
| 172737734 | This changeset was fully reverted in the changeset/172748179 since: OSM follows de-facto: There is no on-the-ground evidence support that Vietnam had controlled Xisha Qundao (Paracel Islands, which are under Chinese control). |
|
| 171765876 | in 172209633 |
|
| 171765876 | Reverted since no response over days. |
|
| 171478512 | Reverted in 171789157 since no response. |
|
| 171765876 | Hi, it seemed you continuously deleted the roads to change the boundary but they can still obviously be seen on the satellite images (both iD's background images and other latest sources). OSM follows "on the ground" principle, meaning you should not make fake deletion. Therefore, you have broken too many relations in the changeset. Please stop doing this, and the changeset be reverted. |
|
| 171478512 | Hi, it seemed you also deleted some paths here to change the boundary in Yadong but some of them can still be seen on the satellite images. Could you please provide the evidence of the removal or the change should be partially reverted. |
|
| 170615439 | Hi, it seemed you deleted some roads to change thr boundary but the roads can still be seen on the satellite images. Could you please provide the evidence of the removal or the change should be reverted. |