OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
169825551 5 months ago

Hi and thanks for improving OSM!

Businesses like this one have to be placed on a building they reside in. Right now it points to a random place next to a highway, which is not correct.

Cheers

168898298 5 months ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!

Thanks for your edits, here I just noticed two small things.

* for simple stairs we typically don't create building:part area, but rather draw a simple line tagged as highway=steps.
highway=steps

* Driveways are more suited for reads leading to a house/garage. For parking lots, we use service=parking_aisle

Cheers

168818536 5 months ago

Here again addr:full should be expanded to individual fields.

Opening hours should be conflated.

168817999 5 months ago

Hi,
here again, (in addition to add:full tag) this: "+1 203-846-['9', '4', '5', '0']" is not a valid value for telephone number.
It should be +1 203-8469;+1 203-8464;+1 203-8465;+1 203-8460

Problem is also in opening hours:
Mo 09:00-17:00; Tu 09:00-17:00; We 09:00-17:00; Th 09:00-17:00; Fr 09:00-17:00; Sa 10:00-16:00

Should be simplified to Mo-Fr 09:00-17:00; Sa 10:00-16:00

I would suggest to revert all import changestes, discuss and review your proposal with members of OSM first and then redo the import.

168818593 5 months ago

Hi,
Sorry where was this import discussed?

The problem I see here that addr:full is not good way how to add address to POI. Especially it should not replace good address data that was already parsed to addr:* subfields.

113974011 5 months ago

I believe that if the multipolygon relation has only a single member (which is the outer way) then is should be deled and the tags moved to the closed way.

113974011 6 months ago

Hi,
Any particular examples? As far as I know I wasn't creating any new objects and majority of edits were changing tags.

98474823 6 months ago

Diki za upozornenie ale to bol niekto iny.

https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/902508489

168291768 6 months ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!

All looks good. Thanks for your edit.

Cheers

167757051 6 months ago

Hi,
The correct way to tag driveways is
highway=service + service=driveway.

driveway=residential is not documented.

service=driveway

167654557 6 months ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!
Just a comments to your edits. When removing businesses please leave the address intact. The address typically stays and is reused for a new business that will come after.

Cheers

166310928 7 months ago

Hi, no problem you're doing good.
When editing you just select the library point. Then on the left side scroll down through the Edit Feature panel until you reach the table with all tags. Click on "+" to add new tag. Into first field type "ref" and into the second field type the number e.g. "37246'.

Then remove the "Charter #150569" from the name.

The actual names that you mentioned are good to stay in the "name" field, but I think the street names should just be removed since that is not their real name.

166310928 7 months ago

Hi and thanks for contributing to OSM!
I think you did a good job, the only issue I see here are the names. e.g. "Quaker Ln S Little Free Library Charter #37246" Those seem to me like a descriptions rather their actual names. These should be removed.
Perhaps if the number is a reference number or id then that can be moved to the "ref" tag e.g. ref=37246

Cheers

165917425 8 months ago

Unfortunately, the node is not added automatically. I believe the purpose is to interconnect the sidewalk and road networks in order to make them routable. If the sidewalk does not share a node with a road then routing software can't give you directions accurately.

"Marked" mean that there are markings painted on the road, but there are no traffic signals. You can find more info on osm wiki: crossing=*
Cheers

165955453 8 months ago

Thanks for catching that!

165917425 8 months ago

Hi Casey,
just a bit of feedback on these sidewalks.

1) When a sidewalk crosses a road (highway crossing) it needs to share a node with the road. We also typically tag it as highway=crossing.
see: node/5052106351

2) The sidewalks you drew are not very accurate. When drawing, try closely following the aerial imagery and place the nodes along the sidewalk centerline. Try also including more nodes as well. Particularly in curves so the shape is more smooth instead of being jagged.

Cheers

165310263 8 months ago

Hi,
I know what you mean, but as far as I know the general agreement is that these segments are necessary for waterway network connectivity. Sometimes the can be tagged as waterway=flowline
waterway=flowline

153692501 8 months ago

That's true, could also be permissive.

165061904 8 months ago

Hey! You are doing a great job Zack! I really appreciate the patience you put into drawing these land covers.

Just in this case I saw that the lakes were supposed to be part of the Wildlife area, but not a part of the forest. And the only way was to re-draw the wood polygon.

Also at this point you are doing quite advanced stuff. Might we worth for you to look into using JOSM instead of iD.

164963890 8 months ago

Hi and Welcome to OSM!

If you enjoy adding new streams then I recommend switching background imagery to LiDAR terrain. There you will be able to see streams clearly even through a thick vegetation.
Just press B and and select "CT ECO Shaded Relief (2023)".