OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
146531432 almost 2 years ago

Hi, when drawing elements like fairways, greens, etc. do not create overlaps between them.
Please see here for more details:
leisure=golf_course#Common_mapping_pitfalls

146154332 almost 2 years ago

Hi Alizar19,
the roof structures that you created (building=roof) are meant for buildings that have no sidewalls and have only a roof. For example covered gas stations. see. building=roof

I assume you wanted to draw different parts of this school building. For that you have to use building parts tagged as 'building:part=yes'. See this wiki page for more details.
building:part=*

146188237 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
here again your forest areas overlap with reads and ponds.
way/1239147752

Could you please draw the areas in a way that they stop at the edge of a road/highway. Also if there are other non-forested areas inside the forest (e.g. ponds, swamps,..) please create a multipolygon instead and add those areas as 'inner' member.
osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon

146041051 almost 2 years ago

Hi, I noticed that you are adding a lot of forest polygons over CT. I am just wondering how do you decide on the shape of those areas? I personally noticed a few issues in those edits:

1) Your wood polygons overlap areas where there are no trees e.g. roads or water areas.
This polygon (way/1238124492) overlaps with Valley Road and Old Mill Road. And also overlaps with Norvein Hier Dam water area (way/1073434387).

2) This wood polygon (way/1238124494) you attached to 'Brinton Road' and now they share a node.

3) Many of the polygons that you created have their shape is very coarse. Like how did you decide on the shape of the polygons that I linked? From what I see in the imagery, the trees continue to be around houses and all the way to Sperry Road.

Cheers
Mashin

145820415 almost 2 years ago

Hi and welcome to OSM.
Is this business really a restaurant? Name sounds very unusual and the building appears to be a residential house.
Cheers

145053817 about 2 years ago

Hi. The question is what is it called now. If no one knows what 'Rock House' is, it wouldn't be useful to have that as a name.

144982224 about 2 years ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!
Thanks for your edits, but please be careful. I noticed that a lot of times you created duplicate objects.
e.g.
here you created this node:
node/11017175927
Which is a duplicate of the hospital that exists as an area:
way/442099131

144021140 about 2 years ago

Hi Jack, I feel like these might not be really a park. Park is more like when there are trees, paths to walk on, maybe benches to sit and relax. These areas look to me as more oriented towards sport use.

leisure=park
landuse=recreation_ground

143802009 about 2 years ago

Awesome, thanks for the great work on CT streams!

142087620 about 2 years ago

Hi vamsisai, thanks for getting back to me and also thank you for fixing the edits.
Cheers
Mashin

143802009 about 2 years ago

There is also "CT ECO Shaded Relief" layer in case the imagery makes it hard to see the streams.

141891962 about 2 years ago

Awesome, thank you!

126325452 about 2 years ago

That's a good point. River areas are not supposed not even have names, those should be only on waterway=river/stream lines.
I removed the name from the relation that had the way as outer member.

141891962 about 2 years ago

Thanks, but are you saying that Lisa's Court is correct or is it Lisa Court?

142210621 about 2 years ago

Hi,
just one thing I noticed. Please be careful to not delete important tags when merging objects. In this case you removed wikidata and gnis:feature_id tags.
When merging objects you can select both and then press "C" to keep all the tags from both objects.
Cheers

142087620 about 2 years ago

Hi,
I would like to ask for more information about this tagging campaign. What is the meaning of hgvtrimble=delivery tag? And also, was this editing efforts somewhere discussed or documented?
Thank you

142114584 about 2 years ago

Hi,
adding golf=fairway tag to those lines is incorrect because all those fairways are already part of fairway multipolygons.

141891962 about 2 years ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!

Question. Are you sure about the street name? If you zoom here in the sign it says Lisa's Court. (https://www.bing.com/maps?cp=41.515256%7E-73.405195&lvl=19.0&pi=-4.5&style=x&dir=46)
Also I don't see any traffic restrictions so it seems that ownership is private but the access is unrestricted.

140847420 over 2 years ago

Hi, I noticed several edits like this one in a rapid succession. Is this a scripted editing or is it a organized editing campaign?
Also in your edit you just added a single node without changing the overall geometry of the road. Could you please elaborate on the purpose of these edits?
Thank you.

140604473 over 2 years ago

Thanks for helping out on this challenge!

Here's one tip. The best imagery to use is either "Esri World Imagery (Clarity) Beta" or "CT ECO Orthoimagery (2019)".
In case there are still too many trees obstructing the view of the stream, try switching to: "CT ECO Shaded Relief". It's almost like an X-ray vision :)