Changeset When Comment
72718006

Hi, just a question regarding your climbing rock node/6653071640/history

Do you know if the tag "climbing" was correct? I see that a user removed your "climbing" tag.

That specific user did dozens of very controversial changes in the region that had to be reverted. I was wondering if one should also revert your "climbing" tag.

62449909

I've recently tried to survey the source but could not find it. Maybe the small waterfall from the creek crossing the path is the source that you mapped?

Just asking so we can if needed link the panoramax image to the source and re-locate it above the path

https://api.panoramax.xyz/fr/index?s=fp;s2;pba57f534-ed57-44fd-8338-2e5c77f4eba4;c101.50/-3.66/0;m18.5/47.0055687/8.56425;va;udefault

Source:
node/5896089929/history#map=19/47.005419/8.564326&layers=NG

190268959

Exactly, I hope that's fine for you :) I felt a node would be more adequate in that case.

190320204

See this post for more detail:
https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/does-this-qualify-as-a-path/147364/13

190313019

See: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/does-this-qualify-as-a-path/147364/14

189343164

See discussion: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/does-this-qualify-as-a-path/147364/13

188781512

See my question addressed to you in this post:
https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/does-this-qualify-as-a-path/147364/11

188781512

See my changeset description. The T5 route was not marked as Street but as Scramble. See OSM for definition of scrambling.

way/1550066971/history/4

188781512

Please do not just revert the changes, you were included in the dicussion:
https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/does-this-qualify-as-a-path/147364/6

183237825

Thanks for adding the Panoramax images :)

177412799

Just for your info, from the wiki page the safety_rope tag should not be used for the via ferrata. I'd remove it and hope it's fine for you :)

osm.wiki/Key:safety_rope

188676730

See https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/does-this-qualify-as-a-path/147364/10

188676582

See https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/does-this-qualify-as-a-path/147364/10

173161686

I'd suggest continuing the discussion in the forum thread for more clarity. See my answer there

173161686

Hi, I saw you added this path. From what I remember, there is no such a path on the ground, no path on the official map, and looking at the Strava heatmap this is not really a path.

I see your intent to show that we can connect the two peaks, but in my view we should not map it as a path.

Can we remove it?

way/1441548153/history

way/1441548153/history

165945056

Hi, regarding this path are you sure that it exists?

way/1384383098/history/1

It appears that almost nobody is taking it and I surveyed the region and no path was visible.

Based on strava heatmap, the access to the building at the end of that path is with a different route hiking up along the river

184700737

* "track" instead of "path"

Anyways, do you agree it's a path?

184700737

Given that @Makeena you reverted it already twice this to "path" instead of "track", do you have a source?

You're welcome to have a different opinion, but it would be best if you discuss and source it instead of keep changing it

187422513

It looks (from the discussion below) like the panoramax image ID was incorrectly linked to that path instead of linking to a neighbor path.

I suspect he didn't want to fix it and prefered deleting it

changeset/187231252#map=17/47.355470/8.494846

164906393

Thanks for the explanation! I had actually surveyed the path the day before your edit and uploaded a GPS trace from my walk to confirm its location. The path was overgrown in places, but it was still physically present and walkable. My understanding is that in OSM we generally map features that exist on the ground and use tags to describe their condition or any access restrictions, rather than deleting them. If there was a fence blocking one end during your survey, that would certainly be useful to map as a barrier or with appropriate access tags. Based on my survey, I think the path should remain in the database with tags reflecting its condition.