ASMapper's Comments
| Changeset | Taatumi | Kommentti |
|---|---|---|
| 173765029 | nuin 7 tiimaa sitten | @Taya_S
|
| 173765029 | nuin 7 tiimaa sitten | The relation was concerning the territories claimed by Syria. Whether it’s possible to retake these territories is completely irrelevant to the relation. Your political views on the matter are irrelevant as well. These articles (and this one as well https://english.enabbaladi.net/archives/2025/10/al-sharaa-the-golan-is-syrian-territory-and-we-are-trying-to-regain-it-through-negotiations/) clearly show that the Syrian claim is still official policy, even if you see it as promoted by a third part. Bottom line, and as said earlier, the relation is still relevant. |
| 173765029 | nuin 10 tiimaa sitten | A quick Google search gave me these two very clear and recent cases of Syria’s remaining claim over the Golan Heights (https://www.aa.com.tr/en/middle-east/syria-welcomes-123-nation-vote-demanding-israeli-withdrawal-from-occupied-golan-heights/3760827# and https://www.israelhayom.com/2025/10/26/syria-demands-return-of-the-golan-heights-amid-arab-pressure/). A map, and one of such secondary importance in its respective post, is barely an adequate evidence to support your claim. |
| 173765029 | nuin 12 tiimaa sitten | Despite the regime change, the policy regarding the question of sovereignty over the Golan Heights has NOT changed. The new Syrian Government, along with the UN and pretty much every other country, still claims the Golan Heights as Syrian territory. Therfore, this relation is as relevant as it have always been. |
| 161866555 | 11 kuukautta sitten | Hi,
|
| 158464776 | noin 1 vuosi sitten | I do agree that the population seems low, especially when compared to estimates of current population. But that's the number provided in the 2004 census, the most recent census conducted in Syria I believe. Either the authorities used a more conservative definition of the city's borders giving lower number, or the city grew at a rapid pace in the last 20 years. Whatever it is, I have no more detailed and confirmed number other than the one I used. Others, while they might reflect the current reality better, are just estimates. If you, or others, disagree with me and prefer to use a more recent estimate, I won't stop them. I just used what I thought was the most recent good data we have. |
| 146667590 | lähes 2 vuotta sitten | As a Syrian, I agree 5000%, but I believe the borders in OSM reflect the de facto borders and not the de jure. That’s why I made a relation with the legal borders of Syria. |
| 142859807 | noin 2 vuotta sitten | Hi,
|