Changeset: 99862876
Following a number of complaints, reverting some Facebook tagfiddling. See https://openstreetmap.org/changeset/99736842 et al.
Closed by SomeoneElse_Revert
Tags
bot | yes |
---|---|
created_by | osmtools/30252 (linux) |
Discussion
-
Comment from SomeoneElse_Revert
This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 99309253, 99310580, 99310631, 99389158, 99389369, 99389571, 99389772, 99390318, 99390600, 99390713, 99390828, 99391056, 99391435, 99401711, 99401870, 99402182, 99402324, 99402465, 99480873, 99480921, 99481044, 99481261, 99481393, 99481544, 99484665, 99484914, 99485074, 99485203, 99485298, 99485313, 99485644, 99485786, 99486006, 99486224, 99486260, 99486338, 99486566, 99486614, 99486723, 99486820, 99558640, 99558872, 99559271, 99559523, 99559801, 99560461, 99561774, 99565658, 99615341, 99615946, 99618439, 99618499, 99618573, 99618619, 99618979, 99621542, 99621688, 99621868, 99622091, 99622127, 99622178, 99622195, 99622212, 99622227, 99622244, 99622261, 99622456, 99623982, 99624066, 99624114, 99624125, 99624132, 99624143, 99624157, 99624179, 99627398, 99627403, 99627414, 99627453, 99627469, 99627496, 99627525, 99627559, 99627585, 99627639, 99627740, 99627758, 99627766, 99627782, 99627799, 99643024, 99643055, 99643099, 99643123, 99643166, 99643193, 99643228, 99643498, 99643619, 99643708, 99643720, 99643758, 99643786, 99643900, 99643975, 99644068, 99644122, 99644158, 99644195, 99644756, 99644813, 99644910, 99644957, 99645031, 99645168, 99645231, 99645616, 99645742, 99645840, 99645884, 99645941, 99666645, 99666845, 99666855, 99666863, 99666879, 99666892, 99666918, 99666939, 99666951, 99666966, 99667009, 99667030, 99667061, 99667227, 99667321, 99667353, 99667399, 99667411, 99667474, 99667494, 99667506, 99667516, 99667533, 99667559, 99667608, 99667631, 99667672, 99667727, 99667754, 99667767, 99668249, 99668268, 99668327, 99668378, 99668399, 99668432, 99668481, 99668499, 99668526, 99668550, 99668579, 99668587, 99693848, 99693896, 99693950, 99694021, 99694109, 99694177, 99694269, 99694428, 99694475, 99694696, 99694830, 99694888, 99694932, 99695157, 99695213, 99695240, 99695323, 99696533, 99696578, 99696746, 99696917, 99696969, 99697456, 99697553, 99697671, 99697768, 99697798, 99697831, 99705330, 99705347, 99705398, 99705417, 99705528, 99705541, 99705601, 99705616, 99705665, 99705714, 99705749, 99705794, 99705822, 99705864, 99705893, 99705924, 99706980, 99717609, 99717670, 99717748, 99717834, 99717920, 99717993, 99718063, 99718151, 99718393, 99718440, 99718687, 99718754, 99718837, 99718908, 99719159, 99719210, 99719308, 99719378, 99719432, 99719494, 99719574, 99719771, 99720870, 99736059, 99736118, 99736208, 99736309, 99736420, 99736525, 99736842.
-
Comment from SafetyIng
Sorry, what?
You revert actuall the contact:facebook-Scheme
Facebook-Pages are no websites. Where do you have discussed this? -
Comment from SafetyIng
Often you destroyed also the tagging of contact:facebook with the facebook-URI (now there is only the username)
-
Comment from SomeoneElse
@SafetyIng Can you give examples of objects where there is a problem?
-
Comment from SomeoneElse
For completeness, the DWG was aware of a number of complaints (see https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/99736842 among others) and received a complaint on Monday night. This change just sets things back to how they were before the previous mass edit. It doesn't affect any objects edited since to add other information.
-
Comment from SafetyIng
No, sorry. The returning of contact:facebook to website is false.
an website of facebook is everytime owned by facebook self. A facebook page is only an subelement of the facebook-Webpage.
Because of that there is the contact:facebook-Scheme. -
Comment from SomeoneElse
@SafetyIng So to be clear, you're not aware of examples of any objects where there is a problem where "now there is only the username"?
-
Comment from SafetyIng
Then you have to ask more clearly. Examples:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/29053098
I couldn't even begin to look through all of them. But this is effectively an overall action fuss that has extremely deteriorated the information content and diluted. -
Comment from Mateusz Konieczny
@SafetyIng
This is revert of automated edits done in violation of https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/29053098 was apparently edit that got caught in sea of automated edits. I restored this specific contact:facebook edit
-
Comment from Mateusz Konieczny
It is possible that other edits done in https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/99484665 were also not harmful but this edit was also done in violation of https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct (or it was manual edit, made in way that looks like automatic, without proper changeset splitting at the same time as making "selected by overpass, checked by python, uploaded manually" automated edits)
- Gasthaus Tiefenau (200214868), v7
- Riversdale Leisure Centre (263280734), v4
- Jugendclub Terra Nova (44799273), v7
- Gasthöfli Aesch (400694956), v4
- Slagerij Hans en Ann (883798336), v3
- Holledauer Hütte (46753078), v6
- Porcobrado (551049978), v4
- Wendermühle (293897904), v5
- Zamparco (443751934), v6
- Le Delizie Siciliane (292006869), v7
- Steinernes Wirtshaus (700173592), v4
- Høng Hundeskov (680680565), v4
- FF Döbeln - Limmritz (724160346), v5
- Bar kampo Miren (903011921), v3
- House of Hair (188212807), v5
- Casa Ela (415982901), v5
- Restaurante Ribeiro Frio (129320456), v10
- Ciliegia Drink & Food (836133124), v3
- VigoHype Skate Park (189928806), v4
- Yo-Co (196476219), v5
- Aanrijroute Lus Borculo (MTB Achterhoek) v.a. Woodbrooke (11363866), v4
- Verbinding Lussen Gorssel -> Oostermaet (MTB Achterhoek - MTB Salland) (10833217), v3
- Verbinding Lussen Vorden -> Gorssel (MTB Achterhoek) (11330589), v5
- Fattoria (8264296), v4
- A.S.D. Montevirginio Mini Rugby (10001025), v4
- Top Foto (3649043), v5
- Sentiero dei Castagneti (12199133), v10
- שביל ואדיות חיפה (3734116), v79
- Fazenda Agrikuvango (11511781), v4
- Dirtbahn Bad Schwartau (5624600), v4
- Verbinding 1 Lussen Zutphen -> Gorssel (MTB Achterhoek) (10832786), v5
- Sentiero 5 "Colle e dintorni" (11248785), v4
- Dirt Park Groningen (6981628), v4
- Verbinding Lussen Lochem -> Vorden (MTB Achterhoek) (10699029), v9
- MTB-route Markelo (5394737), v41
- Rocca di Montefiore (2965449), v7
- Verbinding Lussen Borculo -> Ruurlo (MTB Achterhoek) (11966057), v3
- Ciel Bulumba Beach Club (9751577), v11
- Paupers Graveyard (5813206), v3
- Zanderhof (1270845), v10
- Nino's Galerie (5356396752), v3
- Il Corallo da Arduino (4201858312), v4
- Kunstleihe Harburg (7131386418), v3
- PIZZERIA ALPACINO (7434228724), v3
- Lansuplant (4711284146), v4
- Anguriara Da Giovanni (6697085895), v4
- Strosseggwirt (623556705), v7
- Damaskus Tor (6840976597), v5
- Fuego (5066909359), v6
- Mantica (6474852285), v3
- Addict Coffee (7123254650), v3
- Zur Linde (4335156455), v7
- MESNI BUTIK BIŠTEKA (2399466373), v8
- Clear to Sea (6375924145), v4
- U Lampione (2358308703), v8
- Naustið (4763604523), v5
- Tabac Vap Number One (5016879822), v3
- Nata Community Library and Cultural Centre (6301948703), v3
- Bawa Mode New Image (5069383024), v4
- Pizzeria Etna (4342406121), v5
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |