Changeset: 88621266
Ligne Périurbaine 64
Closed by Lejun
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (16731 fr) |
---|---|
source | BDOrtho IGN; JOSM Validator ; ginko.voyage |
Discussion
-
Comment from EvanE
Hi Lejun
You changed in Besançon a roundabout (https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/470505796) to one circular bridge.
This has two disadvantage:
1. This doesn't fit the reality on the ground, only two parts are a bridge. Compare with the footway inside the roundabout.
2. This chance breaks at least nine long distance bus routes (Flixbus). Didn't check the local bus routes yet.So I intend to revert these parts of your changeset within a few days.
EvanE
-
Comment from Lejun
You're absolutely right, I've been working on local bus routes these past few days and may have been a bit tired in order to do that. I'm not sure to understand how that change breaks bus routes as roundabout junctions are supported by bus relations but you seems more experienced so I'll believe you. Thanks for the feedback !
-
Comment from EvanE
Hi Lejun
Usely nothing happens as long as the route uses the roundabout only once.
If a route pases a roundabout two, or more times (typical for long distance routes like Flixbus) than the automatic sorting is unable to do its work correctly.
Only two parts of this roundabout are bridges, so splitting is neccassary anyway.
EvanE
-
Comment from EvanE
Just look at https://ptna.openstreetmap.de/results/EU/EU-Flixbus-Analysis.html and search for the word "twice".
EvanE
Ways (1-20 of 36)
- 1
- 2
620069047, v2620069048, v2672865297, v2686913160, v2714523672, v2714523676, v2787407435, v2- Rue de l'Amitié (831227889), v1
- 831227890, v1
- Rue de l'Amitié (35920944), v9
- 329086058, v5
- 470505796, v4
- Rue de l'Amitié (538450990), v4
- Rue de l'Amitié (538450991), v4
- Ruisseau (600261071), v2
- Ruisseau (600261074), v2
- Vallon (601137365), v2
- Vallon (601137366), v2
- Valentin (601137388), v2
- Valentin (601137389), v2
Relations (1-20 of 24)
- 1
- 2
- Ecole-Valentin (11357782), v1
- Ecole-Valentin (11357783), v1
- Ruisseau (11357784), v1
- Maisonnettes (11357785), v1
- Vallon (11357786), v1
- Lirenne (11357787), v1
- Valentin (11357788), v1
- Centre Commercial (11357789), v1
- Ecole-Valentin (11357790), v1
- 65. Pôle Témis > Châtillon-le-Duc (Collège) (907248), v47
- Via Francigena - part France - 03 Reims - Besançon (2918033), v206
- 66. Les Auxons → Pôle Temis (5012281), v38
- 65. Châtillon-le-Duc (Collège) > Pôle Temis (5118585), v31
- 67. Pôle Temis > Châtillon-le-Duc (Chemin des Tilles) (5119272), v17
- Flixbus N1720: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Mainz, Hbf. (9929281), v93
- Flixbus N1720: Mainz, Hbf. => Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos (9987166), v86
- Flixbus 720: Grenoble, Busbahnhof => Stuttgart, Airport Busterminal (SAB) (10054632), v74
- Flixbus 720: Stuttgart, Airport Busterminal (SAB) => Grenoble, Busbahnhof (10054633), v66
- Flixbus 1799: Paris, Bercy Seine => Mühlhausen, Bahnhof (10386918), v24
- Flixbus 1799: Mühlhausen, Bahnhof => Paris, Bercy Seine (10386919), v22
- Fauvette (7761318303), v1
- Lirenne (7761318304), v1
- Lirenne (7761318305), v1
- 7761318306, v1
- 7761318307, v1
- 7761318308, v1
- 7761318309, v1
- 7761318310, v1
- 7761318311, v1
- 338815132, v9
- 386869293, v5
- 386869294, v5
- Clos des Pins (672297262), v4
- Châtillon - Clos du Fort (672297266), v5
- Espace Valentin (1431078470), v4
- Centre Commercial (1431093182), v4
- Centre Commercial (1431093183), v4
- Mairie (1431093184), v3
- 1992943587, v4
- 3359121028, v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |