Changeset: 82787416
Revise my previous attempt at road classification in eastern SLC. If anyone has suggestions for the Sugar House area please let me know, because implementing an adequate classification in that region is vexing me...
Closed by Oregonian3
Tags
changesets_count | 116 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.17.2 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | OpenStreetMap (Standard) |
locale | en-US |
Discussion
-
Comment from Oregonian3
To expand on the issues I'm having with roads in Sugar House...2100 S west of 1300 and 1300 E south of 2100 are clearly the main roads through the area, and should be primary. Wilmington is clearly more important than all the other unclassified roads in the area, and should be tertiary. However, 1100 E/Highland is what's causing the issues. North of 1700 S, 1100 E is clearly tertiary, and it's definitely secondary south of 1700 S. However, this makes the secondary road stop at a weird place (a tertiary road). What's more, the part of Highland north of 215 is definitely secondary, but the part south of 215 I think should be tertiary (horrible traffic light timing at 2700 S and 1300 E, and better routes nearby in 1300 E and 900 E). But if I make the road tertiary, then it puts on equal importance to Wilmington, which is clearly incorrect. Any suggestions? In my edits here, I solved the second issue by making 1300 E primary between Highland and I-215, but it seems like a hack to me...
I'm also having issues with where to end the secondary classification on the east side of South Temple. Directly east of 700 E, it's definitely still secondary. But by the time it reaches 1300 E, it's definitely only tertiary. But there's no obvious place in between to switch classification. Thoughts?
- 300 South (785681839), v1
- 400 East (785681840), v1
- 1300 South (785681841), v1
- 700 East (785681842), v1
- 100 South (785681843), v1
- 700 East (785681844), v1
- 2300 East (785681845), v1
- 400 East (10127482), v72
- 1700 South (10127505), v25
- 500 South (10128206), v48
- 900 South (10132156), v39
- Saint Mary's Way (10135779), v9
- Oak Hills Way (10136366), v8
- 200 East (10141763), v47
- 1300 East (10142127), v24
- 900 South (10142984), v38
- 1700 South (10144651), v23
- West Broadway (10149528), v22
- 700 East (32896559), v58
- State Street (36019205), v23
Relations (3)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |