Changeset: 80979434
splitting underground platforms lengthwise to accommodate stairs/escalators/elevators
Closed by clay_c
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15806 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from oba510
I'm not sure it makes sense to tag the stations themselves as "level=-2". I would consider the entire facility (the concourse level, platform level, elevators, etc. to be the station. It would make sense for the individual elements inside the station to get a level tag though.
-
Comment from clay_c
I see what you're saying. I would consider the platform level to be the relevant level to assign to the station, the rest being just indoor pedestrian circulation. Either way, I guess it's unclear whether the level tag belongs on the station node in the first place.
I want to think through to alternate ways of mapping stations. Station polygons fulfill the same role as station nodes, and they're drawn as a convex hull around the stops and platforms (and switches if present). If I were to trace the station polygons here, should I assign them a level tag? If so, what?
The most straightforward answer to me would be to have one polygon for each station, and to assign it the same level as the railway infrastructure it surrounds. I'd like to hear your thoughts.
Ways (21-36 of 36)
- 1
- 2
- 1 (370555336), v11
- 2 (370555337), v9
- 512975766, v12
- 2 (550601228), v6
- 550601239, v6
- 551273355, v8
- 551273358, v6
- 551273359, v6
- 2 (654563343), v3
- 1 (654563344), v3
- 654563358, v4
- 654563359, v4
- Muni Metro (675076114), v2
- Muni Metro (675076115), v2
- 2 (769483925), v2
- 1 (769483926), v2
Relations (1-20 of 34)
- 1
- 2
- Muni Metro N inbound: Ocean Beach => Caltrain (63223), v82
- Muni Metro T inbound: West Portal => Sunnydale (63250), v83
- Muni Metro M inbound: Balboa Park => Embarcadero (91022), v95
- Van Ness (1069505), v6
- Muni Metro L inbound: SF Zoo => Downtown (2124174), v47
- BART Yellow Line: Pittsburg/Bay Point => SFO Airport => Millbrae (2827683), v47
- BART Yellow Line: SFO Airport => Pittsburg/Bay Point (2827684), v41
- BART Yellow Line: Millbrae => SFO Airport => Pittsburg/Bay Point (2827685), v47
- BART Yellow Line: Pittsburg/Bay Point => SFO Airport (2827686), v37
- BART Red Line: Richmond => Daly City (2851509), v25
- BART Red Line: Daly City => Richmond (2851511), v32
- BART Red Line: Richmond => Daly City => Millbrae (2851612), v38
- BART Red Line: Millbrae => Daly City => Richmond (2851613), v39
- BART Blue Line: Dublin/Pleasanton => Daly City (2851725), v26
- BART Green Line: Warm Springs/South Fremont => Daly City (2851726), v36
- BART Blue Line: Daly City => Dublin/Pleasanton (2851727), v32
- BART Green Line: Daly City => Warm Springs/South Fremont (2851728), v39
- Muni Metro J inbound: Balboa Park => Embarcadero (2877693), v27
- Muni Metro J outbound: Embarcadero => Balboa Park (3433311), v22
- Muni Metro K outbound: Embarcadero => Balboa Park (3433312), v20
Nodes (1-20 of 33)
- 1
- 2
- 7209649085, v1
- 7209649086, v1
- 7209649087, v1
- 7209649088, v1
- 7209649089, v1
- 7209649090, v1
- 7209649091, v1
- 7209649092, v1
- 7209649093, v1
- 7209649094, v1
- 7209649095, v1
- 7209649096, v1
- 7209649097, v1
- 7209649098, v1
- 7209649099, v1
- 7209649100, v1
- 7209649101, v1
- 7209649102, v1
- Civic Center (2150077196), v12
- Embarcadero (2150077198), v14
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |