Changeset: 79406036
Split Pacific Coast Highway into a dual carriageway
Closed by shadty
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15390 en) |
---|---|
source | Mapbox |
Discussion
-
Comment from mueschel
On at least 10 ways you changed the attributes maxspeed:forward and maxspeed:backward to maxspeed and maxspeed:1.
There are also two bicycle routes that seem to be broken - both directions run along the northbound oneway street.
Please fix this!
-
Comment from shadty
Hi,
As part of my edit, I had to split the segment to dual carriageway during which I had to remove the forward and backward tags. As the neighboring segment had only one cycle path, I had continued to add it. However if you suggest I shall add it on both ends.Please advice!
Looking forward to learning more from you.
Thanks,
-
Comment from mueschel
The maxspeed tags are now definitely wrong, please add only the correct one to each way.
About the cycle path - check the situation on ground. Currently there is no cycleway tagged and the route makes cyclists use a oneway street in the wrong direction.
-
Comment from sskalyan
Hi,
I have fixed cycle routes by assigning north and south bound routes. But, we are not clear of maxspeed tags since we are remote mappers we didn't tampered existing tags. We just followed tagging methodology of adjoining segment (https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/399543200#map=18/33.72625/-118.08047). Please refer to this link. If you are aware of local speed limits, kindly let us we will add them accordingly.
Thanks in advance,
Kalyan -
Comment from mueschel
The speed limits where all properly tagged before your edit. Just check the history of all the ways.
-
Comment from mueschel
Can we still expect you to fix this issue?
-
Comment from sskalyan
Hi,
I have modified maxspeed tags uniformly according to connecting segments. changeset:80457805. Please let us know if you have any other issues.
Regards,
Kalyan -
Comment from mueschel
That's still not correct.
E.g. this way
http://osm.org/way/399677993
had a 'maxspeed:backward=55', but your new way running in opposite direction has 'maxspeed=45'. -
Comment from sskalyan
Hi,
The segment you have mentioned is a child segment created by our editor while creating dual carriageway. Parent segment for the mentioned segment is way: 399677993
https://snipboard.io/HKJugc.jpg (please refer to the URL for deep history screenshot) which is then a bidirectional road has three maxspeed related tags.
maxspeed, maxspeed:forward and maxspeed:backward, these tags are contradicting in nature, so we have removed forward and backward values since we have made segment into dual carriageway. Maxspeed values are fluctuating and not clear along this stretch of Pacific Coast Highway, to solve this I propose adding OSM note so that local mapper with sufficient knowledge in local speed limits can verify and do modifications accordingly. As per the information I have provided it is clear, that we did not add multiple speed limits.Honestly,
Kalyan -
Comment from mueschel
You deleted valuable information. There are plenty of sources (e.g. Mapillary) to check that the formerly tagged maxspeed:forward and maxspeed:backward were indeed correct.
The 'maxspeed' tag was there, but simply overridden by the two more specific tags.Please stop destroying data and invest in some proper training about OSM!
-
Comment from sskalyan
Hi Mueschel,
I didn't understand your point on how to add maxspeed:forward and maxspeed:backward for a uni-directional road. Please help me in understanding that information. As per your inputs, I have gone through the mappilary imagery of entire road stretch and identified the right maxspeed tags and updated them in OSM (80528644). Let me know if any further changes are required.
Regards,
Kalyan
Ways (1-20 of 30)
- 1
- 2
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177124), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177125), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177126), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177127), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177128), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177129), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177130), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177131), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177132), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177133), v1
- Pacific Coast Highway (762177134), v1
- Mariner Drive (13297626), v4
- Anderson Street (13309226), v7
- Pacific Coast Highway (13342094), v20
- Pacific Coast Highway (27449151), v20
- Pacific Coast Highway (27449152), v12
- Pacific Coast Highway (27449311), v16
- Pacific Coast Highway (30374653), v13
- Pacific Coast Highway (30374655), v18
- 53191882, v4
Relations (4)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |