Changeset: 76170960
Žymėjimo tvarkymai
Closed by Tomas Straupis
Tags
created_by | reverter_plugin/35084;JOSM/1.5 (15390 lt) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from user_8491044
what's the point of making the map out of date, as most people use maps for gps
-
Comment from Tomas Straupis
1. Lanes should not be mapped as separate ways.
2. Ways must form a correct (non intersecting) routing graph.
3. Using POI editor (iD) is incapable of creating data of even medium complexity.Point 1 was a deciding one for revert, reinforced by the fact that there were numerous new routing errors created.
-
Comment from user_8491044
1. Without lanes being mapped as multiple roads how else can i make it work, correct, abide the road law. (that's why i asked for a review, but got no discussion from you)
2. Those 3 intersects that are not intersections, i just had no other idea how to make a road that follows the road signs and that was the best way i managed to do it.(it was a warning not a error, another reason for a review..)
3. So we should just not do it then? I mean there is no other choose, another editor won't fix 2 lanes that aren't going the same way? Or we should just not map difficult roads? -
Comment from Tomas Straupis
This is just a roundabout. It is now (and it was) mapped as a roundabout (I adjusted size/position according to latest changes).
And yes, you're correct, lanes do not have to be mapped as separate ways in OpenStreetMap.
I do not know what iD shows as error or warning as I would not suggest anyone using this editor. In my opinion iD is meant to simple things: add new POI's and change names of existing ones. -
Comment from user_8491044
I mean the biggest problem is that it's no longer a proper roundabout(you cannot go in a circle) and that's why the edit was made. And now the map isn't up to date, nor is it correct by road signs.
-
Comment from Tomas Straupis
It is still a circle.. You still go in circle and leave the circle on first, second or third exit. Lanes are not mappable by separate vectors. Especially on such a tiny roundabout. In principle it is exactly the same type of roundabout as the "new type" roundabouts in Vilnius, which are much larger and still are not mapped with separate ways for lanes.
-
Comment from user_8491044
It was only mapped/updated because the "new" roundabout is special. You cannot go in circle, there is a barriers that force you to take a exit(if you enter a wrong lane you still have to take the exit).
So providing more information for GPS is a bad thing now. I shouldn't do it because people didn't do it in Vilnius? -
Comment from Tomas Straupis
It is still just a roundabout. Coming from any direction you can exit on any direction moving in circular fashion. Current mapping was still made with POI editor so has a lot of routing errors. You have to fix those or I will fix it my way: revert it to correct state. And also note, that other Lithianian mappers will also remove such mapping when they find it as it does not conform to Lithuanian mapping rules.
Ways (1-20 of 21)
- 1
- 2
- 4871654, v21
- 4931037, v10
- 4931038, v13
- Aukštadvario g. (23309303), v16
- Aukštadvario g. (35958463), v11
- A16 (35958464), v10
- A16 (35958465), v9
- 187390563, v6
- 374959154, v7
- 431686342, v4
- 456124039, v5
738307321, v2738307322, v2738307323, v2738307324, v2738307325, v2738307326, v2738307327, v2738307328, v2738307329, v2
Relations (4)
- 31451317, v7
- 31451318, v7
- 31451319, v6
6913342776, v26913342777, v26913342778, v26913342779, v26913342780, v26913363676, v26913363677, v26913363678, v2- 31451320, v7
- 31451321, v14
- 31451322, v9
- 32441981, v11
- 32441982, v6
- 420327600, v5
- 420327602, v6
- 420327607, v6
- 420327609, v6
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |