Changeset: 75431986
added parts of the citywall together to a site
Closed by TWHB
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15390 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | Maxar Premium |
Discussion
-
Comment from dieterdreist
in this changeset there were added "parts" of the citywalls that are not there any more, or that even have never been there (e.g. the pyramid of Cestius was itself part of the walls, there was not a wall going through it and there is not now). Also adjacent there was one the Aurelian walls but it has been torn down by Mussolini almost 100 years ago.
Can you please explain what the basis for these edits was? The above are only examples, I have not looked into everything yet. -
Comment from dieterdreist
The Aurelian walls are not a "site", they are city walls, i.e. it is a generally linear feature, and the remains are interrupted, it is quite different to a "site". https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/10129640
-
Comment from TWHB
I have changed the pyramid and wall next to it, however I do believe that the relation is a "site" see: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Historical_Objects/Relations
-
Comment from dieterdreist
Thank you for fixing the error you had introduced at the pyramid. From looking at the historical_objects page in the wiki that you linked, I did not read it as if site relations were ok for city walls, rather the "type=collection" type seems appropriate, although the page also clearly states that this will result in completely misleading rendering in their map ("The corresponding icon will be displayed in the centre of gravity of the member coordinates") as it will place a marker in the centre of the city, for a feature that is about its border. I agree that we are not tagging for a specific renderer, so this is not a reason to avoid it.
- 732761474, v1
- Mura Aureliane (44639492), v15
- Mura Aureliane (44639497), v17
- Mura Aureliane (191484464), v5
- 191484504, v4
- 191484516, v2
- 191484519, v2
- 191484523, v2
- 191484540, v2
- 191484541, v2
- 191484545, v2
- 191484550, v3
- 191484558, v2
- 191484562, v2
- 204144578, v5
- Mura Aureliane (204145793), v2
- 349334219, v3
- Mura Aureliane (687345945), v2
27524192, v13144078983, v7
Relations (12)
- Mura Aureliane (10129640), v1
- 2582486, v2
- 2582488, v5
- Porta Asinaria (2582489), v8
- AMA Piramide (9535345), v2
2582476, v22582477, v22582478, v22582479, v22582480, v22582481, v42582487, v5
Nodes (8)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |