Changeset: 75310127
Verbetering fouten fietstags
Closed by JanFi
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15322 nl) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from Peilscheibe
Hello JanFi,
could you please explain why you have removed the specific location information of cycle lanes and tracks like on this way https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/212772822 and others?
Why should it be an improvement to OSM to replace a specific information with a less specific one?
Regards, P. -
Comment from JanFi
Because the information which was there was erroneous. The cycleway there is an adjacent lane hardly separated from the motorcar lane, the seperately drawn cycleways indicate a well-separated cycle track. It might give more details about the exact location of the cycle lane, but is faulty as for the type of facility.
-
Comment from Peilscheibe
This is not what I'm talking about. The road mentioned in my comment above has two painted bike lanes, one on each side. No physical separation and there's no separate cycleway mapped. No error in mapping so far.
Another example: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/244428566
There's a physical separation on both sides, it was mapped as cycleway:both=track which seems more accurate than just a cycleway=track.
So I'm still raising the question why you have reduced information content and accuracy.
Regards, P. -
Comment from JanFi
There is no loss of accuracy, only a loss of verbosity. Both tags mean exactly the same. Admittedly, for technical reasons, a few roads with a cycleway:right=* have historically been mapped with cycleway=*.
Adding :both is a recent invention, and most software does not recognise it (e.g. OpenCyclemap doesn't), a reason not to use it.
Thre are about 50,000 ways in Belgium with cycleway=*, without the 'both'. If you promise to check all of them and convince all producers of software, including OpenCyclemap, to use it, I shall promise never to remove a tag like that again.
- Brusselsesteenweg (731826215), v1
- 731826216, v1
- Dooren (731826217), v1
- 731826218, v1
- 731826219, v1
- GO! Basisschool 't Kasteeltje (731826220), v1
- Lindenlaan (731826221), v1
- Prins Leopoldstraat (731826222), v1
- Avenue de Longwy (731826223), v1
- 731826224, v1
- 4310292, v10
- Ringfietspad (4319326), v7
- 4319327, v12
- Ringfietspad (4319334), v11
- Ringfietspad (4319338), v9
- 4332660, v3
- 4332682, v4
- Sint-Denijslaan (6590896), v24
- Ganzendries (7219878), v16
- Ooststatiestraat (7975845), v9
- TEC 72 Battincourt Centre - Arlon Gare - Quai 3 (5390570), v50
- TEC 72 Musson École Spéciale - Arlon Gare - Quai 3 (5390572), v50
- TEC 72 Musson École Spéciale - Arlon Gare - Quai 3 (5390573), v48
- TEC 72 Musson École Spéciale - Arlon Gare - Quai 3 (5390574), v50
- TEC 72 Saint-Léger Rue du 5 Septembre - Arlon Gare - Quai 3 (5390576), v56
- TEC 72 Stockem IMP - Athus Gare (5390578), v49
- TEC 167a Arlon Gare - Quai 3 - Athus Gare (5397794), v24
- TEC 167a Arlon Gare - Quai 3 - Athus Écoles (5397795), v26
- TEC 167a Arlon ISI - Athus Écoles (5397799), v33
- TEC 167a Arlon ISI - Saint-Mard Gare (5397800), v45
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Athus Gare (5397801), v34
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Baranzy Cercle au Chêne (5397802), v37
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Centre Sportif (5397803), v47
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Gare (5397804), v29
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Gare (5397805), v29
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Gare (5397806), v41
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Gare (5397807), v38
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Gare (5397808), v42
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Gare (5397809), v42
- TEC 167a Arlon TEC - Rue des Genêts - Saint-Mard Gare (5397810), v42
Nodes (1-20 of 28)
- 1
- 2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |