Changeset: 72302707
Syntax opening_hours rule: range [ status ] [ comment ]; ERROR = Mar 15-Jun 15 off; "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen"; CORRECT = Mar 15-Jun 15 off "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen". NOT ";" (suggesting second rule without range), NOT " || " (fallback_rule)
Closed by deleted
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15238 en) |
---|---|
source | Osmose; User AnkEric; https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:opening_hours; https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:opening_hours/specification#explain:fallback_rule_separator |
Discussion
-
Comment from user_242798
If "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen" ("Closed for breeding season") then [opening_hours = Mar 15-Jun 15 off] is insufficient information.
No explanation as to why this path is closed.
Also [opening_hours = Mar 15-Jun 15 off] is NOT an absolute rule. Time range might change during season or for different seasons.
No breeding birds (anymore)? Area is - now - Open!
Or: Area was not closed, but breeding birds are in the Area. Area is Closed!
Bald eagle: male builds two nest, female will choose one. Only one Area needs to be closed for "breeding season". The other might be opened.
Therefore I have tried to resolve by:
[opening_hours = Mar 15-Jun 15 off; "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen"].
But Osmose was still complaining: "Invalid Opening Hours ".
Because of " ; " it was suggested "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen" is a different rule, not having a time range specified.
But "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen" is ment as Comment to the rule [Mar 15-Jun 15 off].
Therefore correct is: [opening_hours= Mar 15-Jun 15 off "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen"].
rule: range [ status ] [ comment ]
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:opening_hours;
Also note "<fallback_rule_separator". The rule which follows after this separator (" || ") will match every time frame not covered by previous rules.
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:opening_hours/specification#explain:fallback_rule_separator
This is a structural Error (user: AnkEric).
But correcting will be a challenge, because correcting errors - too often - is considered as "Undiscussed Mechanical Edits".
First action: wait and see for Osmose tomorrow. -
Comment from user_242798
Osmose agrees.
Therefore decided to correct my own errors.
Also replace "Gesloten tijdens broedseizoen" ("Gesloten" is redundant to "off") by "bird breeding season" (English language Comment).
These updates can be considered as "undiscussed mechanical edits".
I protest: there is nothing "mechanical" to these edits, only "JOSM".
I'm allowed to make hundreds of (stupid) mistakes with OSM, but I'm not allowed to correct my own mistakes?!
Ways (10)
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (348033836), v9
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (399445974), v11
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (399446220), v11
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (399535988), v9
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (399536004), v9
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (443225482), v5
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (443225483), v5
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (443225484), v5
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (443225485), v5
- Boerenlandpad Weipoort (483124976), v5
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |