Changeset: 71618006
Improved public_transport tagging for train routes and stop_areas; added highway=bus_stop to some bus stops too
Closed by MacLondon
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15155 en_GB) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from aharvey
Hey there, I've added the new node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6571334825 for Central station, however Central station was already mapped at https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/34891023 as an area. Per one read world feature = one OSM object, we should only have one Central railway=station, and I think it should be the area. Could we delete the one you added and replace it from the relations with the way?
-
Comment from MacLondon
Hi. I agree. I had another look at the station and also noticed a public_transport=station area that you created, https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/679354513. For relations, I've now used that area instead of the (now deleted) node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6571334825.
I've also created a stop_area for T4 stop/Platforms 24/25 at https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/9774952 that you might have a look at.
Is it reasonable to have a separate railway=station node https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5692089433 for the light_rail trains? I suspect it is, but I don't know if the location of the T4 platforms should maybe mean a shift of the light_rail station node eastwards is needed.
-
Comment from MacLondon
Sorry, ignore the question above as I just realised that T4 isn't light_rail.
-
Comment from aharvey
Ah thanks, you're right https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/679354513/ is the public_transport=station and https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/34891023 is the railway=station, per the wiki, one is more the passenger's view of the station, and the other the train's view of the station.
I don't think your T4 stop_area makes sense to me, but then again I don't really understand the stop_area tag...
Platform 24/25 are just two platforms at Central station, I don't think the need to be marked differently to any other platform at Central station.
-
Comment from Warin61
You have tagged the outer way of a platform as a platform. That would be ok if it were not part of a relation that tags it as a platform as well ... duplicated tagging leads to confusion.
-
Comment from MacLondon
Hi Warin61.
I've had a look at this changeset and I can't find the duplicated tagging that you're referring to.
-
Comment from Warin61
Ok,
Example (might be more than one.. I have done some repair work here in 'Central' so I'm not too worried by it .. but something to watch out for)
Way: 229029020 This changeset (dated 6/26/19) add the tags for it to be a platform.Pre-existing Relation: Platform 8 (6015394) established 2/29/16 already tagged as a platform. Thus a duplication.
Ways (17)
- 34891014, v14
- 34891015, v14
- 34891017, v18
- 34891018, v16
- Martin Place (142747518), v6
- Bathurst (165488316), v8
- Harden (198549420), v2
- 1 (224023929), v3
- 2 (224023930), v3
- 229029020, v12
- Dulwich Hill Station (314054674), v11
- St Peters Platform 1 & 2 (327071003), v5
- St Peters Platform 3 & 4 (327071004), v4
- 462008690, v4
- 462008691, v4
- 475164684, v3
- Bardwell Park (507279787), v4
Relations (20)
- Bathurst (9724266), v1
- St Peters (9724267), v1
- Airport & South Line (9724268), v1
- Airport & South Line (9724269), v1
- Bardwell Park (9724270), v1
- St James (9724271), v1
- Central (9724272), v1
- Bankstown Line (2166474), v36
- Airport & South Line (2167463), v80
- Cumberland Line (2167565), v39
- Melbourne XPT (2665103), v318
- Canberra Xplorer (2666822), v33
- Griffith Xplorer (2666850), v73
- Sydney (3134295), v4
- Eastern Suburbs & Illawarra Line (3165566), v28
- Blue Mountains Line (3780800), v19
- Dulwich Hill railway station (6987159), v2
- Hurlstone Park railway station (6987167), v2
- Airport & South Line (9698880), v3
- Airport & South Line (9698883), v2
- Bathurst (6571334823), v1
- Museum Station (6571334824), v1
- Central (6571334825), v1
- Wagga Wagga (1477492396), v4
- Central (1560309432), v3
- Central (1561119546), v3
- Central (1561119548), v3
- Central (1561119550), v3
- Mascot (1572445745), v4
- Wolli Creek (1572445831), v3
- Central (1573080522), v3
- Central (1573080524), v3
- Redfern (1576401445), v4
- Redfern (1576401446), v6
- Redfern (1576401453), v3
- Sydney (1576444942), v5
- Riverwood (1584296190), v3
- Revesby (1584296294), v3
- Padstow (1584393287), v3
- East Hills (1584393438), v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |