Changeset: 68104286
Fix with Osmose
Closed by GBAB
Tags
created_by | Osmose Editor |
---|---|
source | Osmose |
type | fix |
Discussion
-
Comment from aceman444
Hi, what was wrong on roundabout way 662224412? Why is removing oneway=yes useful (I know junction=roundabout implies oneway), but how does Osmose flag it as error?
-
Comment from GBAB
Dear Aceman444,
nothing was wrong with it I just made OSM a bit simpler. As far as I remember, in OSMose it is among the JOSM validator switches on the end of the list. (There is no specific checkbox for it.).
Kind regards
Gábor -
Comment from aceman444
Hi, 'simpler' is relative, and while oneway on roundabout may seem redundant, it at least isn't wrong and is safer. It is similar to the implied oneway on highway=motorway. Not all applications assume that. So it is always safer to add oneway and e.g. toll explicitly (whether yes or no).
I don't think JOSM valudator has such a rule. I always add oneway onto roundabouts and the JOSM validator never reports it. Maybe the Osmose test is outdated or wrongly claim this check is from JOSM. -
Comment from GBAB
Dear Aceman444,
I have found the reference on Osmose:
https://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/errors/?item=4020&class=101
Cheers
Gábor -
Comment from aceman444
Thanks.
Ways (221-237 of 237)
- 31 (626906923), v2
- A. Celli Paper s.p.a. (628461484), v2
- 1 (635701672), v6
- 1 (644825901), v3
- 1 (644825902), v3
- Hódmezővásárhely - Maroslele kerékpárút (646060892), v4
- Hetényegyházi pihenőhely kelet (655010716), v5
- Hetényegyházi pihenőhely nyugat (655010717), v5
- Körmendi út (661865726), v6
- 63 (662224412), v3
- Körmendi út (663606453), v4
- 2407 (666740737), v3
- 2131 (667007693), v2
- 62 (672485114), v2
- 1 (672774622), v2
- 1 (672774623), v2
- Tavacska (675881253), v2
Relations (2)
Nodes (1-20 of 87)
- 26672161, v15
- 392604663, v4
- Fermata urbana 0101 V.B. Peruzzi 68 (429993580), v2
- Fermata N. 0123 L.le D. Minzoni (459271546), v2
- Fermata n. 0057 V. Garibaldi (459282396), v2
- indicazioni (610151801), v3
- 772932744, v4
- Bagni diurni comunali di via Paolo Veronese (939972840), v5
- ŠK Tempus (1171688325), v4
- 1255059230, v2
- 1282733776, v2
- 1427837499, v3
- Cinema Sant'Agostino (1490181940), v2
- Istituto C. Cennini (1491145480), v4
- Divaška jama (1609309607), v4
- Albergo Poderino S. Cristoforo (1728123834), v3
- 1805171259, v4
- Parco Eroi di Basovizza / Park Bazoviški junaki (1851714623), v2
- Ufficio Postale di S. Anna (1906009309), v2
- Banco Popolare - Agenzia di S. Anna (1906009800), v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |