Changeset: 62857525
railway L161
Closed by StijnRR
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (14178 nl) |
---|---|
source | Urbis 2017 aerial imagery |
Discussion
-
Comment from sladen
This changeset deleted the ventilations shafts in Square Ambiorix:
* https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/335986442/history
* https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/335986443/history@StijnRR: please try to make smaller changes + use edit summaries/descriptions, so that it is easier to debug + repair mistakes.
-
Comment from StijnRR
First, I can't help that there is often so much to correct, repair or improve even on or near a short stretch of railway.
Second, my edit summary is clear: I was working on railway line L161.
Third, I made no mistake there. There is no building, nor a ventilation shaft there. The railway (although still below ground level) is twice in the open air: the tunnel is interrupted. The 'hole' is as wide as the railway bed. That's not a shaft anymore. So I cut the long tunnel in shorter parts and removed the tunnel and layer tags from the short stretches which are in open air. This is a valid (and I'd say, a better) way of mapping the situation. There are ventilation shafts further north in the Boulevard Clovis (tagged with man_made=air_shaft) and south in the Boulevard Charlemagne (not mapped). But man_made=air_shaft is a dubious tag (used only 48 times in OSM). Man_made=ventilation_shaft is used more often, but is not a documented tag on the wiki... -
Comment from sladen
Solution would be to repair/adjust the tagging, rather than deletion.
Would `landuse=railway`, + `barrier=retaining_wall` on the two outer sides be acceptable?
-
Comment from StijnRR
Of course. Adding landuse, retaining walls or embankments are things I usually don't get around to. My changesets are big enough already . ;-)
- L161 (627598825), v1
- 627598827, v1
- Chaussée de Helmet - Helmetsesteenweg (627598828), v1
- Chaussée de Helmet - Helmetsesteenweg (627598829), v1
- Avenue Rogier - Rogierlaan (627598830), v1
- Avenue Rogier - Rogierlaan (627598831), v1
- L161 (15894819), v16
- L161 (22971517), v13
- L161 (22971518), v18
- L161 (23652739), v24
- L161 (23771291), v14
- Chaussée de Helmet - Helmetsesteenweg (29131946), v9
- L161 (30570469), v15
- L161 (30570500), v10
- 48337754, v7
- Avenue Monplaisir - Monplaisirlaan (112306036), v9
- L161 (116495188), v8
- L161 (124901617), v6
- 135255371, v4
- 144537663, v5
Relations (1-20 of 24)
- 1
- 2
- L161 (57639), v145
- De Lijn 358 Leuven - Kortenberg - Brussel (237251), v123
- De Lijn 270 Brussel Noordstation - Keerbergen Kerk (239795), v112
- IC-16 Bruxelles - Luxembourg (241358), v189
- S8 Bruxelles - Louvain-la-Neuve (251388), v99
- S4 Aalst - Vilvoorde (252399), v42
- De Lijn 358 Brussel Noordstation/Bruxelles Gare du Nord - Kortenberg - Leuven Station (1612491), v104
- De Lijn 270 Keerbergen Kerk - Brussel Noordstation (1635783), v89
- De Lijn 272 Machelen Cargo Discount Parking - Brussel Noordstation (1635784), v87
- De Lijn 272 Brussel Noordstation - Machelen Cargo Discount Parking (1635785), v91
- Chaussée de Helmet - Helmetsesteenweg (3066212), v8
- De Lijn 270 Brussel Noordstation - Keerbergen Kerk (3480496), v61
- De Lijn 270 Keerbergen Kerk - Brussel Noordstation (3480497), v58
- IC-16 Luxembourg - Bruxelles (3920818), v55
- STIB/MIVB 65 Gare Centrale/Centraal Station - Bourget (6067300), v31
- STIB/MIVB 65 Bourget - Gare Centrale/Centraal Station (6067301), v27
- De Lijn 620 Anderlecht Erasmus - Zaventem Luchthaven Perron A (7363735), v14
- De Lijn 620 Zaventem Luchthaven Perron A - Anderlecht Erasmus (7363736), v15
- S4 Vilvoorde - Aalst (7389116), v4
- S8 Louvain-la-Neuve - Bruxelles (7391070), v18
- 5924443334, v1
- 5924443335, v1
- 5924443336, v1
- 5924443337, v1
- 5924443338, v1
- 5924443339, v1
- 5924443340, v1
- 5924443341, v1
- Y.Josaphat (5924443342), v1
- 5924443343, v1
- 5924443344, v1
- 5924443345, v1
- 5924443346, v1
- 5924443347, v1
- 5924443348, v1
- 5924443349, v1
- Bruxelles-Schuman - Brussel-Schuman (5924443350), v1
- 5924443351, v1
- 5924443352, v1
- 5924443353, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |