Changeset: 51794993
Ashgabat added a bus stops and a bus_bays
Closed by Polyglot
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (12717 en) |
---|---|
source | Aşgabat (high resolution) |
Discussion
-
Comment from apm-wa
Would it not be better simply to set the tag shelter=yes on a bus stop (highway=bus_stop) than to draw both a bus stop and a shelter? One entry rather than two?
-
Comment from Polyglot
In fact I see the shelter and the bus stop as 2 distinct objects. The highway=bus_stop/public_transport=platform node as the point to represent the bus stop and the shelter area way as the place where people can take shelter from the elements.
Sometimes I use 1 node from the shelter's way for the highway=bus_stop. Maybe I shouldn't.I realise it's possible to use shelter=yes on the highway=bus_stop node. But we're mapping in more and more detail all the time. In Belgium you'll often find a bench inside that shelter as well and a waste_basket next to it.
I don't think we should be limited in the amount of detail we can map.
On the other hand I'm also strongly convinced it's best using 1 OSM object per bus stop. In the route relations as well. In many parts around Europe I see a tendency to use 2 and then to add both of them the route relations.
I'm starting to describe this here:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/User:Polyglot/Bus_stops_and_routesAnd I tried to create a manual here:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/JOSM/Plugins/PT_Assistant/Mapping_Public_Transport_with_JOSMI also created some screencasts:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCIOXVFq_dQdrkPxcF--dfcA/videos
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (148190975), v17
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (148520161), v16
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (150406129), v15
- 150406135, v3
- 150406137, v4
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (302643118), v10
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (302643153), v17
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (349879517), v10
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (349879518), v8
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (355254067), v10
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (356945643), v15
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (358356795), v10
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (369361613), v8
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (369361617), v26
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (369455448), v9
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (369455450), v10
- Gurban Soltan Eje frontage road (383638966), v3
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (423427531), v4
- Gurban Soltan Eje (2043) (466106026), v7
Relations (2)
- 245912965, v6
- 245914487, v8
- 245914488, v8
- 245914490, v8
- 269513593, v4
- 1033688500, v6
- 1033688512, v7
- 1033688669, v3
- 1033688807, v3
- 1033688830, v3
- 1049866810, v13
- 1049937873, v4
- 1049938652, v7
- 5084796051, v1
- 5084796052, v1
- 5084796053, v1
- 5084796054, v1
- 5084796055, v1
- 5084796056, v1
- 5084796057, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |