Changeset: 51015481
Bus Aachen
Closed by Polyglot
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (12556 en) |
---|---|
source | PDOK aerial imagery Beeldmateriaal.nl 25cm (WMTS) |
Discussion
-
Comment from aixbrick
Hi,
obviously you inadvertently deleted a part of Helmholtz-Ring at Forschungszentrum Jülich and changed there some of the stop_positions (which I created earlier that day) to platforms. Maybe you can also explain more precise, what you have done in this changeset ("Bus Aachen" is very vague because it spans half of the western part of Germany).
Regards -
Comment from Polyglot
I started by downloading a skeleton with the public transport route relations of Aachen. I started doing validation on it and fixed some errors.
Those bus routes seem to go far.
I did notice some ways were missing, but I hadn't realised I was the one who deleted it. Sorry about that. When I had conflicts, I resolved them in favour of the last user, then restarted validation, until most errors were resolved. -
Comment from aixbrick
Thanks for the explanation. Could you please restore the deleted way and the changed stop_positions?
-
Comment from Polyglot
I tried to make things right again using the reverter plugin for JOSM and doing a partial upload of that way.
-
Comment from aixbrick
Thank you :-)
-
Comment from Schlue
Hi Polygot, could you please also fix the relation 2013834 (Deutsche Fußball Route NRW (West)). This is a cycling route not a bus route. Most of the route was removed with your changeset.
After looking into the OSMChange-XML it looks like some other bicycle and hiking routes are also affected. I would propose to revert this changeset and somehow use the XML files. Thanks -
Comment from Polyglot
Something really weird happened to that cycle route. Maybe I shouldn't be mapping when overly tired. (I'm always tired though...). Anyway, I fixed it by going back. I also looked at the other cycle routes and mended them where feasible.
Do you use JOSM? Could you install the PT_Assistant plugin and tell me what you think of how it handles cycle route relations? It's colouring the different 'legs' of where the route splits in different colours. Do you think this helps to map them? The plugin now also indicates when the bicycle and foot routes are not continuous. The problem with that is that very often they are and it's really hard to fix that. The idea was that a mapper would be notified of breaking bicycle and foot route relations when splitting ways, but there are a lot of 'false' positives and it already takes a long time to try and fix the public transport route relations.
Ways (1-20 of 380)
- Friedrich-Ebert-Platz (5727316), v24
- B 266 (14854486), v15
- L 327 (16307940), v21
- B 56 (17447630), v22
- Josef-Schregel-Straße (19754376), v17
- B 56 (20343274), v10
- L 162 (20591261), v12
- B 477 (20593633), v7
- B 56 (20599637), v12
- Frankengraben (20634301), v27
- Liebergstraße (22540038), v20
- L 246 (22735126), v10
- L 263 (23195819), v12
- An der Tränke (23248005), v7
- Gereonstraße (23571792), v15
- 23654697, v5
- B 477 (24215296), v22
- B 477 (24215586), v11
- Eisenstraße (24277151), v14
- B 258 (24698757), v16
Relations (1-20 of 227)
- Wasserburgenroute (13239), v759
- RurUfer-Radweg (13404), v314
- L 12 (20312), v186
- Bundesstraße 264 (21331), v226
- L 11 (21477), v181
- Bundesstraße 56 (27013), v824
- Erftradweg (27874), v309
- Bundesstraße 258 (28411), v360
- Jakobs-Pilgerweg Köln - Aachen (35121), v341
- Radverkehrsnetz NRW, Rhein-Erft-Kreis (55609), v198
- Radverkehrsnetz NRW, Rhein-Sieg-Kreis (55610), v962
- Bundesstraße 477 (59873), v294
- Bundesstraße 265 (60397), v316
- Bundesstraße 266 (60415), v297
- L 246 NRW (61590), v40
- L 163 NRW (67279), v202
- L 218 NRW (68440), v55
- L 33 (68559), v68
- L 61 (70081), v38
- K 30 DN (70469), v16
Nodes (1181-1188 of 1188)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |