Changeset: 47888250
Aligned roads to imagery.
Closed by Balarnarnanas
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (11639 en) |
---|---|
source | Digital globe |
Discussion
-
Comment from zalex_ua
Considered as vandalism. Reverted!
-
Comment from Balarnarnanas
Why did you revert this without bringing it up to the community? I aligned roads to imagery and the roads in that imagery are verified by Strava and gps tracks. There are incorrect floating nodes all over this area now after all the reverts. Again, I was trying to help.
-
Comment from zalex_ua
I discussed with our local community how to react and such changes. Considered history of your edits and complains from other users.
And yes, I've read policy for discussions, reverting and users ban.
I didn't want to give you more days to break more things - I investigated many changesets you did last days in Kyiv. I can prove that broke things in your edits !!!I can also ask - why did you perform massive edits without discussing with local community?
Was you sure that you will add a value to OSM?Strava - I checked what they provides in considered area - almost nothing.
Please, don't say me about GPS tracks, I know what's is available in the area - again, almost nothing.
And also I know that I drove all the road on my bike last month and I have own GPS tracks, will be uploaded to OSM soon.Floating nodes? ... heh, do I need to repeat?
I already explained you a lot of things in http://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/47911057 discussion.Looked to your last changesets - you mapped unmaped areas - that's good, thanks. But, why so many nodes on ways?
I'd consider that as 2-3 times more than really required.
Do you understand that technically each node takes some space/memory/etc everywhere?To summarize - do continue to reasonable *create* something from scratch, instead of *editing* already well maped areas !
-
Comment from dudka
Balarnarnanas, who are all these people changing highway statuses in Ukraine? Why did you change classification? Do you use any tool to find suspicious highways?
-
Comment from zalex_ua
yeah, I also observed editing by "keepcalmandmapon" user right after discussed "Balarnarnanas" user. That was suspicious. "keepcalmandmapon"'s edits also contained highway classification changes from residental to unclassified (one example - changeset 47946522, way 440704026).
"keepcalmandmapon" has similar editing activity - different countries, 0 created relations etc. All comments are in english only.
"keepcalmandmapon" didn't reply on my complains but continue to perform maping.Is this similar pattern an accidental one? I don't think so!
I also haw a question in my mind - why so much attention to Ukraine? ... -
Comment from dudka
I found 3 users more: eemc2, master_raster and GeoCrazy. All changing highway=*. That's why I assume you are a team working on one task.
Ways (1)
Nodes (12)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |