Changeset: 37563200
EU: delete coastline because it is all parts composed multipolygon natural=water. There is conccurence on natural=water and natural=coastline object
Closed by jseigneuret
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (9900 fr) |
---|---|
source | Bing 2016, OSM Inspector 2016 |
Discussion
-
Comment from chnav
Have you discussed the matter with other mappers ? Please give a link to such discussion.
Caspian Sea is an exclusion; the coastline guarantee that water will be kept in shape-files which accelerate sea rendering. Firstly someone added tag natural=water then few days later it become a reason to delete coastline. That is not the way things should be done in OSM. -
Comment from chnav
Another hidden problem is such large water polygon may not be fully included in raw osm data of geographic regions, thus missing Caspean Sea. Coastline solve the problem.
Have returned coastline back.
-
Comment from jseigneuret
sorry for that. This is an interpretation error but not for others lakes and reservoir. Have you just reverter inner and outer parts of Caspian Sea for costlines? thanks
-
Comment from chnav
I did reverse coastline, then verify coastline is closed, and some islands direction. No errors in JOSM after that. Will see what OSM Inspector woud say.
Thanks
- Bayıl Qalası (358625702), v6
- Böyük Daş (303644742), v6
- Böyük Zirə - Nargin (249023839), v10
- Daş Zirə (249029547), v9
- Kiçik Çilov (22760699), v13
- Neft Daşları 2 (303809046), v7
- Neft Daşları (295826527), v14
- Zirə Adası (22762007), v6
- Zənbil Adası (22761994), v4
- Çilov adası (22760739), v16
- Ogurja Ada (35971355), v10
- Тюлений (86434181), v4
- остров Нордовый (159774359), v3
- остров Чечень (5227556), v11
- جزیره آشورا ده (30299823), v6
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |