Changeset: 36356089
(no comment)
Closed by Papayaved
Tags
build | 2.4-16-g0c126d0 |
---|---|
created_by | Potlatch 2 |
version | 2.4 |
Discussion
-
Comment from muzirian
hi, why is this retagged as residential highway?
-
Comment from Papayaved
About what road is it? It's big changeset. Residential road type i use for minor road in residentional area
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dresidential
residential – street or road generally used for local traffic within settlement.
unclassified – Unclassified roads typically form the lowest form of the interconnecting grid network (below highway=tertiary roads). Roads serving for interconnection of small settlements. Use residential rather than unclassified on the road section if there are trafic restrictions (such as slower speed limits) or traffic calming features near small settlements.
track - roads for mostly agricultural use, forest tracks
-
Comment from muzirian
I noticed u changing tag to residential for non residential area in thrissur town, which made me write this comment.I had noticed similar edits at other places on kerala too.
Btw India has a page about highway tagging wiki, I suggest u take a look at tht too.
-
Comment from Papayaved
I need a link to the roads for viewing history
-
Comment from Papayaved
Thrissur still does not have a residential, industrial or other areas
-
Comment from Papayaved
and no administrative boundaries of settlements
-
Comment from Papayaved
http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/389512609#map=17/10.51948/76.21833
This road have name, located in residential area, don't have traffic and can be living_street but it's not so narrow
-
Comment from Papayaved
Local rules should clarify general rules, and not contradict them
-
Comment from muzirian
i don't think local rules contradict, but general rules cant be applied globally, aslo some need local knowledge to tag correctly.
-
Comment from muzirian
i ve replied to some of your same messages i got on inbox
-
Comment from Papayaved
I'm talking about this rule:
"This is a useful guideline if you are not sure whether to use residential or unclassified for streets in towns:
residential – street or road generally used for local traffic within settlement.
unclassified – Unclassified roads typically form the lowest form of the interconnecting grid network (below highway=tertiary roads). Roads serving for interconnection of small settlements. Use residential rather than unclassified on the road section if there are trafic restrictions (such as slower speed limits) or traffic calming features near small settlements"and in Indan wiki
Ubran road:
"highway=unclassified
Roads in a neighbourhood that collects local traffic and feeds into the main road""residential - General residential roads in a planned locality. Wide enough to carry two-way slow moving residential traffic. Usually has cars parked by the side and footpaths for pedestrians"
Unclassified roads don't used for street in settlement, it use for interconnection of small settlements. Narrow streets available in all old towns, not only in India.
-
Comment from Papayaved
For example see narrow residential streets in Istanbul
http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/5068368 -
Comment from muzirian
thanx for the tip, replies were very helpful. will try to check the taggings when I'm there again.
-
Comment from muzirian
Hi, i have been to the place again, noticed that some roads are marked wrong as residential road. Road are not just classified according to width or speed limits.
You should check and follow guidelines for each country when tagging. Please check https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dunclassified .
Wrong tagging will create serious confusion for people using it for navigation and also for routing engines.
Im changing type for one road now.will check others later.
- 389512592, v1
- 389512960, v1
- 389512799, v1
- 389512960, v2
- 389512319, v1
- 389512319, v2
- 389512553, v1
- Church Cir (389512609), v1
- 389512610, v1
- Church Cir (147498645), v5
- 389512553, v2
- 389512592, v2
147498646, v4- Kopan Ln (147498758), v4
- 147498759, v4
- Thekke Angadi (147498760), v4
- 254453254, v3
- Pallikkulam Road (100152926), v9
- 254453880, v3
- Church Cir (147498645), v6
Relations (1)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |