Changeset: 34335357
Edited Oak Grove driveways, added three buildings, flagged Safeway 1529 as closed, divided McGloughlin Blvd at Oak Grove Blvd.
Closed by Bickendan
Tags
created_by | iD 1.7.4 |
---|---|
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/id |
imagery_used | Bing |
locale | en-US |
Discussion
-
Comment from Peter Dobratz
There are a number of problems with this changeset. It seems like you have an interest in editing major roads, including splitting and combining them. I highly recommend that you invest some time in learning the standalone editor JOSM instead of the in-browser editor iD. A number of the problems with this changeset would have been flagged as errors or warnings in JOSM, which you could have resolved prior to uploading.
The general idea of splitting McLoughin into a dual carriageway makes sense since there is what looks to be a traffic island separating each side of the road.
I know this has been mentioned before, but in OSM we don't generally abbreviate street names. For the name tag, don't use "SE McLoughlin Blvd", but instead use "Southeast McLoughlin Boulevard". It might be better to copy all of the tags from the existing road onto the new segment you are creating. Then you can just add the oneway=yes tag to each leg and possibly adjust other tags like lanes and sidewalk.
JOSM does a much better job than iD when it comes to presenting Relation objects to you. This segment of road is a part of a number of route relations and a turn restriction relation. I've already fixed the bus route relations as I was editing simultaneously and I needed to resolve the conflicting versions before saving.
There is a right-turn only relation that is now broken because the "to" road of it is disconnected from the "via" Node and the "from" road. However, as this is now a connection from the Fred Meyer parking lot onto what is now a one-way section of McLoughin, the turn restriction is now superfluous and can be deleted.
If U-turns are not allowed at either end of the divided portion of McLoughin, then there needs to be turn restrictions such as "no_u_turn" or "only_straight_on". If you don't know this information, then don't add the turn restrictions.
For the Safeway that closed, don't just amend the text "(CLOSED)" to the name tag. Assuming that the building is still there, just leave the building tag and all the addr tags, but delete the tags that are specific to the Safeway such as name and shop=supermarket. If there were other tags like phone, opening_hours, or website, then those would be deleted as well.
For service roads that intersect buildings (drive-throughs), connect the Way object for the road to the Closed Way object for the building at the points where they intersect. Then split the Way object for the road into 3 objects and put a tunnel=building_passage tag on it.
Overall, it would also be helpful to associate source information with the changeset. Did you actually travel to this location or are you just looking at aerial photos? If you are using iD, I believe you have to put this directly into the changeset comment as you can't edit the other changeset tags, such as source, directly.
Ways (1-20 of 61)
- Southeast Kellogg Avenue (5287442), v5
- Southeast East Avenue (5294357), v8
- Southeast McLoughlin Way (5295666), v8
- Southeast Oak Grove Boulevard (5302876), v17
- Southeast Maple Street (5305818), v9
- Southeast McLoughlin Boulevard (130077348), v10
- 130077362, v3
- 130077378, v6
- Safeway 1529 (CLOSED) (146702219), v2
- Southeast McLoughlin Boulevard (160277064), v5
160280765, v3- 160280766, v3
- Southeast Oak Grove Boulevard (187286368), v4
350686179, v2- 372881386, v1
- 372881387, v1
- 372881388, v1
- 372881389, v1
- 372881390, v1
- 372881391, v1
Relations (6)
- Pacific Highway East (68883), v316
- Bus 33: Clackamas Community College => Clackamas Town Center (229565), v17
- Bus 99: Clackamas Community College => Portland (229566), v14
- 1753412, v3
- Bus 33: Clackamas Town Center => Clackamas Community College (2661790), v31
- Bus 99: Portland => Clackamas Community College (2903422), v15
Nodes (41-60 of 195)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |