Changeset: 30952522
(no comment)
Closed by TheOldMiner
Tags
build | 2.3-650-gad99430 |
---|---|
created_by | Potlatch 2 |
version | 2.3 |
Discussion
-
Comment from Peter W34
The bridges on Marlborough Sarina Road or any other road, should not be changed to service or any thing different to what the rest of the road class is. This wrecks the routing for all the people who use OSM for in car navigation, also all roundabouts should have junction = roundabout tag.
-
Comment from TheOldMiner
I am not sure who this is and what authority you have make such comments without a spread of manners, something I intend to raise with the mailing list, it may be a good idea to not only provide an example but discuss the issue. There maybe a litigimate reason.
-
Comment from Peter W34
I apologize for my bluntness, I am fixing many of the errors in the map using Osmose. I was disappointed to find someone had changed these two bridges on Marlborough Sarina Road to service road, if the bridge is narrow put lane=1 instead. If you look at the history of the Funnel Creek bridge you will see what I mean. Peter
-
Comment from Warin61
Error .. confuses me!
Relation: Develin State Forest (1481424)
Relation: Goodedulla National Park (1481425)Are both the same! The same area should not be a national park and a state forest? Could you look at this please (I hope you are more locale than me).
Reason why I am looking here is that both relations have the same error - they include a way Way: 104639445 and that cannot be joined into a continuous segment - so I have removed it from these relations .. that could now be made simple ways.) -
Comment from TheOldMiner
I would be careful with starting a conversation with the word Error. I worked for the Queensland Department of Natural Resources for 6 years in the land management area. Simply, it is possible to historically have state forest, natural park, land leases and many forms of tenure coexisting in a layered arrangement inland in Queensland. Many areas exist around central queensland where I worked. Up to you if you want to change, but I am happy with the arrangement
-
Comment from Warin61
As a NSWelshman I find the idea of an area being both a National Park and a State Forest strange in this country. However if that is the case then it should remain so in OSM. I have updated the web links for the Goodedulla_National_Park. Oh and the tag natural=forest to natural=wood as that is the present OSM tagging.
I do note that it is not unknown for both forestry and conservation to take place in the same areas .. Europe has a few of them, then again they have 'National Parks' that have had world wars fought on them.
- Johnston Street (250073018), v2
- Noden Street (344019791), v2
- Shinfield Road (204244222), v2
- Marlborough Sarina Road (49872791), v21
- 344020914, v1
- Swayneville State School (344020915), v1
- 344020916, v1
- Marlborough Sarina Road (49872791), v20
- Noden Street (344019791), v1
- Noden Street (160307886), v6
- Noden Street (343344061), v2
- Marlborough Sarina Road (49872791), v22
- West Funnel Creek (164902166), v4
- Crescent Creek (164902183), v2
- Koumala - Bolingbroke Road (174550587), v3
- Marlborough Sarina Road (174462200), v3
- Funnell Creek (164928031), v2
- 233901461, v2
- 233901443, v2
- 121636593, v4
Relations (1)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |