Changeset: 149252903
classified roads based on What is on the Ground, Arial Imagery, Local Knowledge, What it looks like from the ground, actual usage and features such as roundabouts, traffic lights, slow speed limits, single lanes etc
Closed by slice0
Tags
changesets_count | 5041 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.28.1 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | Bing Maps Aerial |
locale | en-AU |
Discussion
-
Comment from fortera_au
Are you able to explain why you’ve dropped the main road out of a town from primary to tertiary?
---
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/149252903
-
Comment from slice0
reasons are in the changeset history above, thankyou.
-
Comment from slice0
@fortera_au as you also have a strong recorded history of purposely and incorrectly removing my edits, citing false reasons which I have a list of. Can you please seek a public consensus in the OSM community forums if you wish to make any changes to my classification changes of which are within the OSM wiki guidelines and based on fact and personal experience.
- Comment from slice0
-
Comment from fortera_au
Considering the roads placement within a smaller, close to country town, those factors are less important in determining a roads classification. If you actually took into consideration the roads use, positioning, compared it to other roads nearby, and even just observed those roads, they’d be more than a tertiary road. They’re the main roads connecting the town to highways, main roads northbound out of the town, and also the heavy vehicle route out of the town.
-
Comment from aharvey
I don't have any local knowledge here, but the physical attributes here are less important (and are mapped as their own objects or tags on the ways for data consumers to consider), based on importance in the road network with this road appearing as the main connector to the town tells me it should have a high classification.
-
Comment from slice0
@aharvey road classifications in Australia are very open to interpretation, nothing you have listed in your comment correlates to any information in the OSM wiki or previous discussions regarding road classifications please move the conversation to the community forum if you wish to have a proper discussion
-
Comment from slice0
you are also part of fortera discord army and fortera has falsely claimed many of my past edits have been "illegal" and "invalid" when that have not been. id take forteras opinion with a grain of salt at this point. he is also the reason why we cant use any official data australia wide which makes it even harder to classify roads correctly. thankyou
-
Comment from slice0
every single time forteras has a fit about the way roads have been classified the "discord army" of opinion always move the goal posts in his favor as shown by what aharvey is doing.
-
Comment from slice0
1 single fact that I can tell you is that this road IS NOT a major arterial road or major highway which is why I removed the "primary" classification to start with. Aharvey if you think that primary classification is correct then you are actively sabotaging the project in order to back up your mate in an argument and nothing more. Read the wiki for primary roads
-
Comment from slice0
if we are allowed to use bylaws as stated in the Primary wiki then is should be classed as Secondary, but our DWG member will ban people for doing that, so we have to improvise, dont you get it?
-
Comment from slice0
I made a new diary entry https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/slice0/diary
- Main North Road (23001693), v19
- 23336729, v18
- Redbanks Road (23336750), v16
- Main North Road (25521071), v16
- Main North Road (32617337), v15
- Murray Street (32617346), v20
- Main North Road (166479114), v9
- Weyland Road (172523292), v6
- Weyland Road (172523294), v3
- Redbanks Road (172523295), v5
- Weyland Road (172523296), v4
- Redbanks Road (172523298), v6
- Redbanks Road (172523299), v5
- Main North Road (172550028), v11
- Main North Road (172565269), v10
- Main North Road (172565286), v7
- Main North Road (172641400), v11
- 205000259, v10
- Main North Road (205000260), v7
- Main North Road (205000261), v7
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |