Changeset: 141216590
Update Winnipeg Transit Route 97 to better match GTFS data
Closed by mf8s003j
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18822 en) |
---|---|
source | http://gtfs.winnipegtransit.com/google_transit.zip |
Discussion
-
Comment from ToniE
Hi there,
just to inform you!
Strange things emerged with the new GTFS feed for Winnipeg:
- Bus 10: Wolseley => Tache => St. Boniface - trip-id=101 now directs to GTFS Bus 10: Eastbound Enfield at St. Mary's => Northbound Aubrey at Wolseley
- Bus 17: Misericordia Health Centre => Seven Oaks Hospital- trip_id 12142 now directs to Bus 676: Westbound North Town at Centre St. => Westbound St Vital Centre Terminal at St. Vital Centre (16 Osborne, 676, 96)
trip_ids seem to be shuffled from one GTFS feed version to the next.
A GTFS feed must be consistent inside the same ZIP file, but there is no need/requirement to keep that from one version to the other.
PTNA fails here and says "GTFS!" trip_id does not exist - but that is only half of the truth. I'll check for the bug in PTNA.
I always had the gut feeling that using gtfs:trip_id:sample and so for a route relation is not a good idea.
For most of the German GTFS feeds, using that is OK, the route_ids and trip_ids are quite stable, don't get shuffled.
route_ids follow a schema: "xx-ref-season-version" where
- xx might indicate the vehicle type
- ref indicates our OSM-ref
- season is s23 tor 2023
- version
- = 1 usually stretches from December to December
- = 2 might indicate a detour from April to May caused by constructions
- = ...
- 1, 2 and ... might be in the data at the same timetrip_ids are derives from route_ids, i.e. a trip_id includes route_id as a sub-string.
This schema identifies who is using the the SW of the MentzDV, e.g. "Transport for London", not only German ones.
Best regards
ToniE
- Burrows Avenue (1207477170), v1
- Fife Street (1207477171), v1
- McPhillips Street (1207477172), v1
- Aberdeen Avenue (1207477173), v1
- Dufferin Avenue (1207477174), v1
- Dufferin Avenue (1207477175), v1
- Main Street (1207477176), v1
- Sutherland Avenue (1207477177), v1
- Argyle Street North (1207477178), v1
- Euclid Avenue (1207477179), v1
- King Street (1207477180), v1
- Jarvis Avenue (1207477181), v1
- Jarvis Avenue (1207477182), v1
- Robinson Street (1207477183), v1
- Dufferin Avenue (1207477184), v1
- Selkirk Avenue (1207477185), v1
- McGregor Street (1207477186), v1
- McGregor Street (1207477187), v1
- Mountain Avenue (1207477188), v1
- Arlington Street (1207477189), v1
- Bus 97: Fife => Point Douglas (16323058), v1
- Bus 97: Point Douglas => Fife (16323059), v1
- Bus 97 (16323060), v1
- Bus 20: Watt & Leighton => Airport Terminal (283893), v78
- Lord Selkirk Park (1773345), v7
- William Whyte (1778343), v7
- St. John’s (1788340), v5
- Inkster–Faraday (1788374), v4
- Mynarski (1790468), v7
- Burrows Central (1818841), v4
- Winnipeg Route 180 (4585396), v34
- Winnipeg Route 52 (4585399), v96
- Winnipeg Route 62 (4585401), v43
- 8323831, v2
- Bus 20: Watt & Leighton => Portage & Tylehurst (16054125), v17
- Bus 20: Watt & Leighton => Downtown (16054134), v13
- Bus 15: Downtown => Church => Inkster Park (16077351), v6
- Bus 15: Downtown => Mountain & Fife (16077352), v6
- Bus 15: Mountain & Main => Wellington => Airport (16077353), v13
- Bus 15: Mountain & Main => Mountain & Fife (16077357), v3
Nodes (14)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |