Changeset: 141072234
Mapping.....
Closed by Superadlen
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18822 fr) |
---|---|
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from spughetti
Hey Superadlen,
I've noticed you've been adding a large amount of buildings, seemingly AI generated. A large amount, some would say the majority of these buildings are too low quality to be on OSM. AI generated buildings should not be imported without thorough checking and fixing which has not been done in your case. Many of these buildings don't even exist which you would have noticed had you checked your changeset before uploading.
Some examples of low quality buildings
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1206674507
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1206674428
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1206674516On top of that some of your changesets have resulted in large amounts of orphan nodes being uploaded, filling the database with unnecessary data.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=18/34.92836/-1.22287 -
Comment from Superadlen
Thank you. Yes, I know about this. There are my friends in our group for creating the map. They are the ones who will take care of this. I am sending large information that I cannot correct at the time
-
Comment from Superadlen
Thank you for pointing that out. But don't worry, I know very well what to do.. I'm just still working on it.. When I finish, the end result will be good.
-
Comment from spughetti
You really shouldn't be submitting unfinished data to OpenStreetMap, especially not when you know that said data is low quality. It's up to you to process and review the data before it's uploaded, not afterwards.
The data you've been uploading is practically worthless, it can't be used for anything because it's highly inaccurate, so uploading it before reviewing has no benefits to either the OSM community or OSM users. In fact I'd say the data you've been uploading is actually harmful, it's full of buildings crossing highways and other buildings.
-
Comment from spughetti
Could you be more specific as to how you are planning on fixing these low quality imports and when you're planning to do so?
In the future when doing huge imports like these you should not only check the data quality before uploading, but also make a wiki page so people can find more information about the purpose and status of the import.
-
Comment from Superadlen
We have a group on Facebook...and we agree on everything there
-
Comment from spughetti
A Facebook group doesn't have the authority to completely ignore OSM guidelines.
-
Comment from Superadlen
I think you do not understand me. We are a group of friends, more than 20 people. We are participating in drawing the map and we are working on that. We also know what to do. Please. Our efforts must be judged when we complete and not now.
-
Comment from Woazboat
No, that's not how OSM works. If you want to import data, you need to follow the import guidelines set by the community. That includes
1) Making sure the data is useful and correct. Promising to fix things 'afterwards' is not sufficient.
2) Getting into contact with the OSM community to notify them about the planned import and to get feedback.While it's commendable that you want to contribute to OSM, the project and its community are bigger than just your group of friends and you are not working in a vacuum.
-
Comment from Negreheb
No, your efforts should be judged now because you continue ignoring comments about the issue. I personally think the account should be blocked until this is discussed in the forum because it seems you simply go on.
There are some issues to unpack
1) it seems multiple people are using your account?
2) you are importing stuff and ignore the importing guidelines.
3) you continue to import wrong data despite knowing that its wrong, simply referring to "well, we just do it later"I created a thread for this issue, you might chime in https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/undiscussed-import-in-algeria/104175
-
Comment from Superadlen
I will do this in the future and make sure to correct everything. Thank you for the advice
- 1206677533, v1
- 1206677534, v1
- 1206677535, v1
- 1206677536, v1
- 1206677537, v1
- 1206677538, v1
- 1206677539, v1
- 1206677540, v1
- 1206677541, v1
- 1206677542, v1
- 1206677543, v1
- 1206677544, v1
- 1206677545, v1
- 1206677546, v1
- 1206677547, v1
- 1206677548, v1
- 1206677549, v1
- 1206677550, v1
- 1206677551, v1
- 1206677552, v1
- 4565492891, v4
- 11181597243, v1
- 11181597244, v1
- 11181597245, v1
- 11181603338, v1
- 11181603339, v1
- 11181603340, v1
- 11181603341, v1
- 11181603342, v1
- 11181603343, v1
- 11181603344, v1
- 11181603345, v1
- 11181603346, v1
- 11181603347, v1
- 11181603348, v1
- 11181603349, v1
- 11181603350, v1
- 11181603351, v1
- 11181603352, v1
- 11181603353, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |