Changeset: 137882922
Serbia: hiking trails and other details between Rtanj and Šarbanovac edited
Closed by Stadtigel
Tags
changesets_count | 1369 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.25.2 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | Bing Maps Aerial;.gpx data file |
locale | de |
Discussion
-
Comment from Komadinovic Vanja
Hi Stadtigel,
I just wanted to discuss your change regarding https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/11097832 .
My name is Vanja and I'm OSM mapper from Serbia. I'm also part of Working group for trails inside
Mountaineering association of Serbia. I'm working on syncing official data we have about trails registered with association into OSM as part of https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Serbia/Projekti/PSS_staze .I saw you changed geometry of trail, and I'm interested in switching from https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1065454226 and going with northern road, what is you source for this change? Is trail marked that way on the ground?
I also saw that you changed capitalization in name "Томићева колиба - јама Леденица" -> "Томићева колиба – Јама Леденица"? I'm using official trail names for OSM name.
Also you changed network from rwn to lwn. We decided when importing data from PSS to use following:
iwn - for E paths and other international trails
nwn - transversals
rwn - for other trails registered with PSSPSS currently does not differentiate trails by length. That's something we plan to work on in the future. ( I updated project wiki just now )
Please let me know what you think about my comments.
Best,
Vanja -
Comment from Stadtigel
Hallo Vanja!
I hiked this trail on May 22nd this year. I recorded following GPS track:
http://stadtigel.bplaced.de/GPS/gps.htm?GPX=2023-05-17bis06-03_E4_Serbien.gpx
I corrected the path as I walked it. There were only a few markings. Therefore it is possible that I missed a variant.
I thought “Јама Леденица” was a proper noun. That's why I corrected the name. Please undo this, if it was wrong.
In the OSM wiki, "lwn" means a local route (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:network%3Dlwn) and "rwn" means a regional route (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:network%3Drwn). In my opinion "Tomićeva koliba – Jama Ledenica" is a local route. If the working group decides that my changes should be reverted, then I will accept that.
With friendly greetings
Stadtigel from Germany -
Comment from Komadinovic Vanja
Hi Stadtigel,
Thanks for informative response.
I will contact club which is maintaining trail and double check with them problematic part of trail since you recently visited it. I propose we leave it as is for now ( per your correction ).
I agree with lwn vs rwn, will work inside Mountaineering association of Serbia on defining criteria. I propose we leave it as is for now ( per your correction ).
Regarding name I will correct it to official one since you are fine with that.
I'm really glad you are using trails in Serbia, please let me know if I can be of any help.
Best,
Vanja
Ways (1-20 of 29)
- 1
- 2
- 1185531252, v1
- 1185531253, v1
- 1185531254, v1
- 1185531255, v1
- Dom Dordevic (1185531256), v1
- 1185531257, v1
- 1185531258, v1
- 1185531259, v1
- 1185531260, v1
- 1185531261, v1
- 1185531262, v1
- 1185531263, v1
- 1185531264, v1
- 406045899, v5
- 694339159, v7
- 741960812, v3
- 741960813, v2
- 741960817, v6
- 741960820, v2
- 741960821, v5
Relations (5)
- Red way (16028424), v1
- Томићева колиба – Јама Леденица (11097832), v4
- Гола планина (11098424), v3
- E4: Krivelj – Sokobanja (14206054), v20
- Red way (15978885), v2
- 11012444801, v1
- 14 (11012444802), v1
- 11012444803, v1
- 11012444804, v1
- 11012496705, v1
- 11012496706, v1
- 11012496707, v1
- Jama Ledenica (11012496708), v1
- 11012496709, v1
- 11012496710, v1
- 11012496711, v1
- 11012496712, v1
- 11012496713, v1
- 11012496714, v1
- 11012496715, v1
- 11012496716, v1
- 11012496717, v1
- 11012496718, v1
- 11012496719, v1
- 11012496720, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |