Changeset: 134724714
single leisure=pitch
Closed by mottiger
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18646 en) |
---|---|
source | swisstopo SWISSIMAGE |
Discussion
-
Comment from dafadllyn
Hi!
I've noticed that you have reduced 2058 tennis courts in the whole of Switzerland to the markings (lines). Was this agreed with the community somewhere?
Kind regards
Raphael -
Comment from dafadllyn
PS: As far as i can remember, all the mapped tennis courts i came across were drawn in such a way that they also included the area between the baselines or sidelines and the fence. I think this makes sense because when you play tennis you are not only inside the lines.
-
Comment from mottiger
Hi
You're right, I should have spoken to the community about reducing the size. I was simply in the flow. Originally, I only specified that the tennis courts were too big. In my overpass query, however, the already mapped tennis courts also came up. I'd be happy to bring this part into the community. I see this point clearly, as it is a massive change to the data.
Nevertheless, I would like to refer to the wiki, which says at https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:leisure%3Dpitch:
"If there is some physical outline of the pitch or painted line markings...".
I see your point that especially in tennis not only the markings are used, however the markings define the pitch. What we map as leisure=pitch.If you think about the picture further, football pitches should not be mapped at the markings, but about 50 cm further out, since the player is no longer on the pitch when the ball is thrown in.
And to stay with football, is the goal part of the pitch or not?A consistent mapping of the pitches makes it possible to make more accurate estimates of the number of pitches based on the areas, if people are interested in areas.
I would like to take the topic of tennis even further and consider drawing an area with leisure=sports_centre around the individual pitches.
Cheers
-
Comment from dafadllyn
Hi and thanks for your reply!
The wiki says '*some physical outline of the pitch or* painted line markings'. Besides, the corresponding Wikipedia article states: 'The field of play generally includes out-of-bounds areas that a player is likely to enter while playing a match [...]'.
But i think we should discuss this with more people (if it hasn't already done) - on the Swiss mailing list and/or on the tagging mailing list.
> I would like to take the topic of tennis even further and consider drawing an area with leisure=sports_centre around the individual pitches.
If i'm not mistaken, a sports centre is a facility where several sports are practiced. A tennis facility isn't a sports centre. But it may make sense to create a new tag for (named) sport facilities.
Regards
Raphael
Ways (1-20 of 24)
- 1
- 2
- 1161066010, v1
- 1161066011, v1
- 1161066012, v1
- 38303520, v3
- 38303523, v3
- 330530139, v2
- 336102618, v2
- 336102619, v2
- 336102620, v2
- 339259465, v2
- 339573243, v2
- 341277988, v2
- 341277989, v2
- 348055292, v3
- 357894508, v3
- 362315500, v2
- 367606545, v2
- 1047451515, v2
- 1160882557, v2
- 1160882558, v2
- 10799142210, v1
- 10799142211, v1
- 10799142212, v1
- 10799142213, v1
- 10799142214, v1
- 10799142215, v1
- 10799142216, v1
- 10799142217, v1
- 10799142218, v1
- 10799142219, v1
- 10799142220, v1
- 10799142221, v1
- 10799142222, v1
- 10799142223, v1
- 10799142224, v1
- 10799142225, v1
- 10799142226, v1
- 10799142227, v1
- 10799142228, v1
- 10799142229, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |